Changes for Rnd 10 v The Doggies

[Swansinger]

Two goals regardless , it is time to give young Sam a rest . Jesse should have been in for him last week.

[Bloodmaniac]

Johnny Longmire, pick Nipper please.

[longmile]

Out: Walsh, LRT and AJ
In: Morton, Mumford (if ready) and Armstrong
TDL to start

If not Mumford bring in Seaby. Maybe Spanger instead of Morton

[Swansinger]

Re :
Seems fair for Walsh to be dropped after not doing anything last night......

coupled with :
.... why should Walsh be the one to get the drop

and :
Spangher in for someone, probably unfortunate Walsh..

The matter of leaving out Walsh seemed to be a rhetorical question ,yet you still say he should be dropped.
Why ?

I'd keep the lad in.

[The Big Cat]

Welcome to the Tigers' site ....... oh sorry .... it's the Swans' site. I just thought supporters eating their own meant ..... oh sorry.

[aardvark]

Welcome to the Tigers' site ....... oh sorry .... it's the Swans' site. I just thought supporters eating their own meant ..... oh sorry.

You obviously haven't been to the Tigers site today

[MattW]

We need confidence, experience, and competitiveness in the forward line. So, Spangher for Walsh.

I think Armstrong for Malceski is on the cards at some point. Also wouldn't mind seeing Cunningham as specialist sub - perhaps for Bird.

We look really one paced at the moment; the loss of Rohan has been considerable. We might need to take risks to overcome it.

[The Big Cat]

You obviously haven't been to the Tigers site today

Just wait!

[lwjoyner]

a few need to be looked at. AJ not just because of injury his decision making since he came in has been poor has has his kicking most times. Bird is anothe rwho has struggled played well early in season,Shaw must be close to being replaced he too struggles with decisions LRT is not a fwd or ruck let him play at CHB at shut down a man as he did early in his career, NM is struggling jees for what its worth a lot are. Its disappointing that one week we play alright the next no. But please dont just recycle like AE. Maybe its time for JMoore to be given a chance. Not quick but smart and hard at it seems to be among the best every week in the reserves.

[swansprincess]

The matter of leaving out Walsh seemed to be a rhetorical question ,yet you still say he should be dropped.
Why ?

I'd keep the lad in.

The first point was completely sarcastic. I do not think Walsh should be dropped, but I think he will be because the coaches seem to so against dropping reid.
For mine, it would be Spangher in, Reid OUT
and depending on injuries, Mummy, Armstrong and Nipper in. For LRT, AJ and anyone else.

[swansprincess]

We need confidence, experience, and competitiveness in the forward line. So, Spangher for Walsh.

Based on this, Reid should be dropped straight away then. He has no confidence, not much experience (not when it comes to kicking goals anyway) and is not competitive. Walsh had one bad game of 2, Sam's had countless pathetic performances.

I do like your suggestion of cunningham though, he's quick and would surely offer more than any 'forward' we have now.

[wolftone57]

Mal, AJ (injured looked like a long term to me), Shaw, love to drop Macca , he was soft and played for frees all night, but it won't happen. Welcome to the Australian Cricket Team!

In Spang, Tommy to second ruck, Harry and Mitch. LRT to the back line. There may be a problem with Harry as he replaced Brown on the list and he comes back this week. Are they going to list him again in place of Rohan or go for Shane Biggs as he is in the best players in the reserves every week. I don't quit know the rule here but I was of the opinion that because Brown came back Harry automatically goes back to the rooky list. Maybe Liz, Scott, Cheer Squad, Ugg or Al will know better.

[ugg]

Rohan was placed on the long term injury list on Friday with no replacement nominated yet.

[wolftone57]

Bugger it bring Mitchell in and play him off the bench he has played 70 min at Two's level and should really have another game there but WTF I think he would be good. He is strong and slippery.

[wolftone57]

Rohan was placed on the long term injury list on Friday with no replacement nominated yet.

I know we can nominate someone to replace him Ugg but is Harry precluded because he has already been a replacement? If AJ has broken his arm that will be at least 6 weeks so he will be on the long term injury list too.