2017 trading, drafting, list management

[Industrial Fan]

Barry caught a few fish.

Just cut the disrespectful mchack @@@@. No need for that.

[barry]

Disagreeing on a few players worth is not trolling.

[barry]

There's wrong-headed and then there's bat@@@@@ crazy. These comments skirt the borderline.

Or is it just good old-fashioned trolling?

Let's say history repeats and we lose another grand final and Rohan has 5 touches again. That's 3 failures in a row. What would you do with him?

[MattW]

Let's say history repeats and we lose another grand final and Rohan has 5 touches again. That's 3 failures in a row. What would you do with him?

We've made the finals and he's been a major contributor in close wins that have got us there. As in, we might not still be a chance to make the GF without him.

[moocher]

I'm just thankful that Barry isn't in charge of our recruitment & trading. I rate Rohan as our slightly more conservative version of Cyril!

[dimelb]

And while we're on the subject of Rohan:

Best friends Gary Rohan, Jed Lamb square off in Sydney Swans, Carlton Blues match

[grarmy]

Not very fair to single out Rohan when most of our guys didn't turn up when it mattered. Only Kennedy (14+16), Buddy (14), Mitchell (16), Rampe (16) and maybe one or two I've missed, actually played well for us

Rohan, Tippett and McGlynne with 11 possessions between them and you want to discuss other players?

[barry]

We've made the finals and he's been a major contributor in close wins that have got us there. As in, we might not still be a chance to make the GF without him.

You didn't answer the question.

[barry]

And while we're on the subject of Rohan:

Best friends Gary Rohan, Jed Lamb square off in Sydney Swans, Carlton Blues match

Sweet maybe Carlton will take him. They would probably be happy just to make finals.

[dimelb]

Let's say history repeats and we lose another grand final and Rohan has 5 touches again. That's 3 failures in a row. What would you do with him?

Depends how many goals he kicks. One or more and he's a keeper!

[MattW]

You didn't answer the question.

Gary's a Swan, trying to win a flag. I don't really like the hypothetical. (But reckon he'll play well in any event.)

[KTigers]

I think the figures below paint a broader picture of these guys performances in the 2014 & 2016 finals series.

2014 Grand Final
Tippo 16 possessions (1 goal)
McGlynn 11 possessions (1 goal)
Rohan 7 possessions
2014 Prelim
Tippo 15 possessions (4 goals)
McGlynn 19 possessions
Rohan 23 possessions

2016 Grand Final
Tippo 10 possessions
Rohan 5 possessions (1 goal)
2016 Prelim
Tippo 13 possessions (2 goals)
Rohan 18 possessions (2 goals)

[barry]

Don't be selective here, if you are going to delve into a final series, do the lot.
2016. QF v GWS. 12 possessions
2016 SF1 v Adelaide. 6 possies.
1 goal between them.

There is a define pattern of failure on the big stage here.

[Bloods05]

Don't be selective here, if you are going to delve into a final series, do the lot.
2016. QF v GWS. 12 possessions
2016 SF1 v Adelaide. 6 possies.
1 goal between them.

There is a define pattern of failure on the big stage here.

Someone who has been consistently disrespectful of Jarrad McVeigh, soon to be a 300-game player, since the start of his career, has zero credibility when it comes to judging players. Sorry.

[barry]

Someone who has been consistently disrespectful of Jarrad McVeigh, soon to be a 300-game player, since the start of his career, has zero credibility when it comes to judging players. Sorry.

Don't be sorry. But we are talking about Rohan here and if you took the time to go back through my posting history instead of making stuff up, you'd see I was one his biggest fans earlier on.