Changes for Rnd 14 V Essendon

[waswan]

How would we know without being aware of what the coaches have asked him to improve and watching the last two NEAFL games? On the plus side, Sinclair is playing as well as he ever has, not that it's amazing, but it's OK.

I think Sinclair hasn't done enough to keep Tippett out as opposed to what has Tippett done
Ressies have won by 260pts in 2 weeks hard to really standout in that crap

Sinclair doing everything except for holding marks and kicking goals, he kicks 1-2 goals a game he stays in.
The irony of this is ex-swan Nankervis took the marks but missed the goals, reckon they had us if he kicked either of those goals

I did love Sinclairs tackle late in the game

[707]

Got to reward NEAFL form so Dawson must be given a run this week. The obvious out is the weakest link from Saturday who basically did nothing, Towers.

Towers whilst he has improve d a little this year is never going to be best 22 but Dawson probably can be bringing a good set of assets. Dawsopn looked a little overawed in nhis debut game and was thrust into a side that wasn't playing well. This weekend Dawson is in even stonger NEAFL form and will be playing with a senior side that is now playing strong footy.

Round 13 coming up, Dawson needs to be given a run of games to show his undoubted talent at senior level. I'll be very annoyed if this swap isn't made this week, Towers doesn't have runs on the board and was all but invisible Saturday.

Sinclair would be unlucky to lose his spot to Tippett, would like Sinkers to stick marks better but is playing as well as we've seen him, certainly has a red hot go.

[Dosser]

I think Sinclair hasn't done enough to keep Tippett out as opposed to what has Tippett done
Ressies have won by 260pts in 2 weeks hard to really standout in that crap

Sinclair doing everything except for holding marks and kicking goals, he kicks 1-2 goals a game he stays in.
The irony of this is ex-swan Nankervis took the marks but missed the goals, reckon they had us if he kicked either of those goals

I did love Sinclairs tackle late in the game

Chatting to a Tiger supporter today who was there at the game. He said that he was really impressed with Sinclair's ruck work and his natural leap meant that he got first hand to the ball nearly every time. Food for thought.

[penga]

Chatting to a Tiger supporter today who was there at the game. He said that he was really impressed with Sinclair's ruck work and his natural leap meant that he got first hand to the ball nearly every time. Food for thought.

Not hard to look good with natural leap against Nankervis and Grigg.

[Scottee]

If you base whether they are injured or not from how they look at the end of the game, half the team would be dropped. Every week Hanners walks of with a noticeable limp.

I don't know whether you have seen it but it definitely very noticable and pronounced (pronounced LIMP, L.I.M.P) and was accompanied by some obvious wincing in pain.

[waswan]

There goes that, Tippett not available

Swans big man to miss another week with injury - AFL.com.au

[Markwebbos]

There goes that, Tippett not available

Swans big man to miss another week with injury - AFL.com.au

We put him in the NEAFL to get fit and he gets injured. Could be a long wait at this rate!

[mattybloods]

Cameron, Aliir and now Tippett injured. I guess Pink will be our primary ruck in the NEAFL?

[waswan]

Have a look at the last 2 weeks
Papley could be our primary ruck in the 2s

[rojo]

McVeigh to play on Friday night v Essendon?????? Wow, surely not! He is not match fit, tall, strong or fast. I would love to see him back but not v Essendon.

Melican and Dawson are the only two I would consider bringing in but I don't know where Dawson sits on the speedy player/physical presence ratings . Both Towers and Hayward are speedy but both get kept away from the ball, or pushed off it too easily. May all depend on match ups again.

[wolftone57]

The coaching staff clearly got the Melican decision right as there was no obvious match up for him. If we assume Grundy plays on Daniher, who's their second tall? I don't know the Bombers team well enough to know them all but I would imagine that Melican will come back in if their forward line requires it.

My feeling is that Franklin will be ok, but it's hard to predict. It was good of Menadue to speak up in his defence though.

Rohan is safe, particular while Cunningham is out. We need his speed and defensive pressure, whether he's playing forward or back (I prefer him forward but I'm sure the coaches have their reasons). Dawson must be getting very close but I think we'll be reluctant to make many more changes than is necessary.

Their second tall is Hooker. Their third is Stewart a 198cm ruckman, ex GWS.

[wolftone57]

There goes that, Tippett not available

Swans big man to miss another week with injury - AFL.com.au

Perennially injured. When has the bloke strung a whole season together without injury?

[Mel_C]

I don't know whether you have seen it but it definitely very noticable and pronounced (pronounced LIMP, L.I.M.P) and was accompanied by some obvious wincing in pain.

Hopefully it was just cramp. At the game I was listening to Triple M and at one stage the boundary rider said that he was struggling to come off with severe cramp.

Sent from my HTC_PN071 using Tapatalk

[aardvark]

Perennially injured. When has the bloke strung a whole season together without injury?

What annoys me most is he's getting paid 4 times as much as Newman/ Papley ect.

[The Big Cat]

Buddy a fine
Jones a week!