2019 trading, drafting and list management: players and personnel
Collapse
X
-
-
I would say Coniglio is going. He hasnt signed yet, and the Giants are making noises about player retention.
Put 1 and 1 together and you get 2. ie. they want more retention powers to retain Coniglio. (which they wont get in time).
So GWS will get a pretty good pick for Cogs, and make getting green and any other academy players they want easier.
If Cogs goes, I cant see GWS interested in any trades with Sydney. If they have retention issues with Victoria, why let a player go who is happy to stay in Sydney.?All opinions are not equal. Some are a very great deal more robust, sophisticated, and well supported in logic and argument than others. -Douglas Adams, author (11 Mar 1952-2001)Comment
-
I'm intrigued by the potential damage this fox could do on the field to the opposition.
I don't think he'd have a negative effect on our culture (even if he were to stuff up). Our club will show players the door if they carry on. They've done this in the past. I do think that the culture of our club could have a positive impact though.
If HB is to get another opportunity at any club, it depends on whether has the fortitude to be a responsible player.
I would be open to a medical and a conversation.Comment
-
Just did the ladder predictor and we came third last. Knightmare has Rowell as third pick behind Anderson and Green. Make it happen!
We just need Carlton to keep going on their winning ways.
Hopefully Suns don't get a priority pick. Timing would suck even if warranted.
- - - Updated - - -
The Rowell Cup?Comment
-
Comment
-
Not sure about Francis. He's a high draft pick but still struggling to become a regular in the Essendon side in his 4th year. He's only played 23 games. He's also more of an interceptor than a one on one defender.
Brad Crouch on the other handComment
-
It seems that the only very good players that we can attract are;
* Players we offer overs to (Buddy and Tippett - isn't going to happen),
* Players getting away from the limelight (Buddy and Plugger), or
* Players wanting to come home (Davis - extremely rare).
There are very few players that fit this bill.
We are going to have to pick the eyes out of who is available and pick a player that isn't getting the opportunities at his current club.Comment
-
There's been talk all season about The Crows offloading one of the Crouch's. As usual, they'll probably want to head home to Victoria and someone like Hawthorn will reap the benefits as usual.
It seems that the only very good players that we can attract are;
* Players we offer overs to (Buddy and Tippett - isn't going to happen),
* Players getting away from the limelight (Buddy and Plugger), or
* Players wanting to come home (Davis - extremely rare).
There are very few players that fit this bill.
We are going to have to pick the eyes out of who is available and pick a player that isn't getting the opportunities at his current club.Comment
-
He had observed that people who did lie were, on the whole, more resourceful and ambitious and successful than people who did not lie.Comment
-
There's been talk all season about The Crows offloading one of the Crouch's. As usual, they'll probably want to head home to Victoria and someone like Hawthorn will reap the benefits as usual.
It seems that the only very good players that we can attract are;
* Players we offer overs to (Buddy and Tippett - isn't going to happen),
* Players getting away from the limelight (Buddy and Plugger), or
* Players wanting to come home (Davis - extremely rare).
There are very few players that fit this bill.
We are going to have to pick the eyes out of who is available and pick a player that isn't getting the opportunities at his current club.
I agree with the last sentence. To my mind, that's been the Swans way. Outside of key forwards. We have a pretty long track record of trading for "stars" even if it doesn't always go according to plan (Tippo). We will have to think soon enough about a replacement for Buddy. I don't think any one on our books has the makings of the number 1 forward.
I had another thought re: Gold Coast. There's been all this talk of Burgoyne being Gold Coast's "Hodge". But Hodge went to the Lions because of his connection to Chris Fagan. So logically it should be a Swans player who becomes the equivalent at GCS. Then I started thinking, which current Swan would be the Hodge of Gold Coast, and only one name came to mind. MACCA!
Well I also wondered about Joey Kennedy!Comment
-
Invitees to the draft combine;
AFL announce 79-man Draft Combine invite list | Zero Hanger
Slim pickings in NSW, especially compared to Vic, WA and SA which is evidence that we need assistance.
Some scouts are suggesting that Rowell is better than Sam Walsh. Shame we didn't lose a few more games.Last edited by S.S. Bleeder; 31 July 2019, 09:54 PM.Comment
-
[/B]
I agree with the last sentence. To my mind, that's been the Swans way. Outside of key forwards. We have a pretty long track record of trading for "stars" even if it doesn't always go according to plan (Tippo). We will have to think soon enough about a replacement for Buddy. I don't think any one on our books has the makings of the number 1 forward.
I had another thought re: Gold Coast. There's been all this talk of Burgoyne being Gold Coast's "Hodge". But Hodge went to the Lions because of his connection to Chris Fagan. So logically it should be a Swans player who becomes the equivalent at GCS. Then I started thinking, which current Swan would be the Hodge of Gold Coast, and only one name came to mind. MACCA!
Well I also wondered about Joey Kennedy!Comment
-
[QUOTE=S.S. Bleeder;781670]There's been talk all season about The Crows offloading one of the Crouch's. As usual, they'll probably want to head home to Victoria and someone like Hawthorn will reap the benefits as usual.
It seems that the only very good players that we can attract are;
* Players we offer overs to (Buddy and Tippett - isn't going to happen),
* Players getting away from the limelight (Buddy and Plugger), or
* Players wanting to come home (Davis - extremely rare).
There are very few players that fit this bill.
We are going to have to pick the eyes out of who is available and pick a player that isn't getting the opportunities at his current club.[/QUOTE
In 2008, 2009 and 2010, we picked up Mattner, Shaw, Kennedy, Mcglynn and Mumford. We need to replicate this to a degree I reckon. Not sure if it can be done anymore.
- - - Updated - - -
.Comment
-
Wild speculation, unsubstantiated rumours, silly jokes and opposition delight in another's failures is what makes an internet forum fun.
Blessed are the cracked for they are the ones who let in the light.Comment
Comment