2021 VFL discussion thread

[TheBloods]

First time watching tier 2 footy?

Were supposed to have good depth but not 1 player out there looked AFL standard

[aardvark]

I reckon Sheather has a bit of X factor. Needs work but he shows promise.

[Aaron]

Were supposed to have good depth but not 1 player out there looked AFL standard

However in the Change for Round 6 Thread you posted:
"Sinclair Stephens Brand Mclean in
Hickey Blakey Melican McDonald out"
Sinclair, Brand and McLean obviously played in this VFL game. You can have your opinion but will you have dumped too many players too quickly?
What is AFL standard? Who is the judge?

[mcs]

However in the Change for Round 6 Thread you posted:
"Sinclair Stephens Brand Mclean in
Hickey Blakey Melican McDonald out"
Sinclair, Brand and McLean obviously played in this VFL game. You can have your opinion but will you have dumped too many players too quickly?
What is AFL standard? Who is the judge?

Its a completely arbitrary measure, based on whatever this weeks flavour of qualitative measures are. That and throw in a bit of irrational hate for a few and you've got what said poster feels 'AFL standard' is.

[TheBloods]

However in the Change for Round 6 Thread you posted:
"Sinclair Stephens Brand Mclean in
Hickey Blakey Melican McDonald out"
Sinclair, Brand and McLean obviously played in this VFL game. You can have your opinion but will you have dumped too many players too quickly?
What is AFL standard? Who is the judge?

Hickey-injured
Blakey-not up to it
Melican-shouldnt have been in the AFL side in the first place
MCdonald-needs a rest

Sinclair-we need a ruck
Stephens-didnt play in the VFL game and deserves a chance. Young gun.
Brand-better than Melican
McLean-fill in for Mcdonald to keep fwd structure

[Aprilbr]

You forgot to mention Hayward. You recently said that it was a waste of time selecting him and he was not up to it?

[707]

You forgot to mention Hayward. You recently said that it was a waste of time selecting him and he was not up to it?

Crickets ........

[Aaron]

Hickey-injured
Blakey-not up to it
Melican-shouldnt have been in the AFL side in the first place
MCdonald-needs a rest

Sinclair-we need a ruck
Stephens-didnt play in the VFL game and deserves a chance. Young gun.
Brand-better than Melican
McLean-fill in for Mcdonald to keep fwd structure

Don't think my questions have been properly answered. Not expecting anyway. Luckily our coaches value our players more and have more patience.

Sent from my vivo 1937 using Tapatalk

[Ruck'n'Roll]

Did no-one else think some players seemed not to be wearing the correct jumpers?

[TheBloods]

You forgot to mention Hayward. You recently said that it was a waste of time selecting him and he was not up to it?

Wont be long til ill be proven right. Good return from him. 1 game.

[TheBloods]

Don't think my questions have been properly answered. Not expecting anyway. Luckily our coaches value our players more and have more patience.

Sent from my vivo 1937 using Tapatalk

How else could i have answered it ? Your worry is that it would be too many changes but i think its worth doing. We are persisting with the wrong players. We know what we get from Blakey, Melican these types most of the time but we still bother with them. Since no one in the 2s was that impressive we should play Stephens .

[ugg]

Did no-one else think some players seemed not to be wearing the correct jumpers?

I think the info on the website is wrong.

[stevoswan]

Wont be long til ill be proven right. Good return from him. 1 game.

Maybe he has turned a corner with that 1 game.....time will tell I guess.

[Ruck'n'Roll]

I think the info on the website is wrong.

Thanks very much ugg

[SwanSand]

Wont be long til ill be proven right. Good return from him. 1 game.

What a joke !
Your comments just lack the one thing that is needed .... credibility !