Changes v Geelong R7
Collapse
X
-
Very surprised about Hickey. I only hope that the initial information given by the club about his injury has incorrect and they haven't bothered to correct it. Otherwise, if he's coming back early from a serious strain / tear of his PCL, then it would rank right up there with putting Sinclair back on after he dislocated his shoulder as a medical clanger.Comment
-
+1 All Horse said was that he trained really well this week. No mention of getting any medical clearance! I wonder if this is now a tactic with our key players in keeping their early return a secret, as with Heeney last week? Buddy is an exception, as his progress is a weekly media obsession!Very surprised about Hickey. I only hope that the initial information given by the club about his injury has incorrect and they haven't bothered to correct it. Otherwise, if he's coming back early from a serious strain / tear of his PCL, then it would rank right up there with putting Sinclair back on after he dislocated his shoulder as a medical clanger.Comment
-
I wonder how much time Hickey will play in the ruck, or whether he’ll replace Reid as fwd/ruck?
I tried to post an article from the SMH in which JPK said Gould was very close to a “rightly deserved” debutComment
-
Comment
-
Same! I can only think it was far less serious than feared initially. Either not a PCL or a very low grade (think I read they can be 3 weeks minimum).
Already feels like a player we really miss if not playing, so let's hope he has some impact.Comment
-
Comment
-
Comment
-
He was decent enough in his first senior game, quiet in the next. Kieren Jack and Nick Smith each had a couple of senior games early in their career where they didn’t quite look up to it. Emerged shortly afterwards with a big bang.
Ling has a shocker last week but had some really good moments in today’s game.Comment
-
Franklin is a liability. He can always be relied on to kick a bag when the stakes are not really that high. When we really need him he either goes missing or kicks 1 goal 5. Every kick for goal is a guess with that round the body style. Watch guys like Tom Lynch kick for goal. That is a full forward.Comment
-
I hope this is posted purely for the laughs valueFranklin is a liability. He can always be relied on to kick a bag when the stakes are not really that high. When we really need him he either goes missing or kicks 1 goal 5. Every kick for goal is a guess with that round the body style. Watch guys like Tom Lynch kick for goal. That is a full forward.
"You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."Comment
-
I’m not sue you saw his first qtr last nightFranklin is a liability. He can always be relied on to kick a bag when the stakes are not really that high. When we really need him he either goes missing or kicks 1 goal 5. Every kick for goal is a guess with that round the body style. Watch guys like Tom Lynch kick for goal. That is a full forward.Comment
-
Comment
-

Comment