If we can match them in the midfield in terms of strength, we can beat them with pace out wide and firepower down forward. For this reason, I'd like to see us use Heeney in the guts more tonight. A centre bounce rotation of Mills, Parker, Heeney, Warner, and occasionally Papley can match the strength of Carlton.
Rd 10 vs Carlton Blues Friday 7:50PM @ Marvel - Pre-Game Thread
Collapse
X
-
-
Some thoughts on Hewett, from the perspective of both teams.
Blue clearance king: Why the Swans’ loss has been Hewett’s gainComment
-
Rampe to reach 200Last edited by neilfws; 20 May 2022, 11:07 AM.Comment
-
It was a mistake , but we wont feel it til a year or two when Parker cant play 4 quarters in mids . Basically relying on Roberts or Gus to be something . I think they will but nothing is guaranteedComment
-
Don’t have to have played to enjoy it or have opinions. Plenty of male obstetricians who have never given birth.
You can still know plenty about footy from watching, without playing.
And given some of the commentators out there, playing footy doesn’t always equate to sensible opinions either.
He then gave the best analysis of the Parker thing you could ever hear...from each player's perspective, from each coaching group's perspective, from AFL perspective and from umpire's point of view.
I'd love to hear him on a weekly basis on different issues, but doubt he'll pop up again.
I have a lot of respect for Whately's views, but also think he's unlikely to open the gate for a possible competitor.
Why would he?Comment
-
Some thoughts on Hewett, from the perspective of both teams.
Blue clearance king: Why the Swans’ loss has been Hewett’s gainComment
-
Need to step in here. Stevo is going out of his way to nit pick Chad. Chad may be on occasion out of position defensively but any run of the mill AFL player can learn to be good defensively.
What very few have is Chad’s line breaking corridor ability. Parker, Mills, Kennedy, Okeefe, K.Jack can’t match Chad for that. The last great Swans line breaker was Adam Goodes. Chads speed, power, agility, skills and confidence to break lines is a rare asset.
In my opinion, one Chad line break is worth 3 Rowbottom defensive efforts.
I think Stevo is besotted with the Paul Roos 2005 defensive midfield players such as Luke Ablett, Brett Kirk, Jared Crouch and Fosdyke. He can see Rowbottom in them.
I think Stevo wishes Chad was another run of the mill defensive midfielder.
Chad though is Chad and his talents are more valuable than a defensive midfielder.
So BS, you can theorise as much as you like.....and all your 'theories' are completely wrong. Defensive midfielder?More defensive when it counts and is needed.....yes.
BTW, TB was doing fine defending himself.....apart from just making some stuff up. I did like his response to your above post though.Comment
-
It might be an interesting off season (time wasting) activity to compile a list of players that have done better than expected after departing the Swans.Comment
-
Comment
-
I enjoy your posts TheBloods and I do rate Rowbottom, I just think it takes time to get to the next level and he's progressing along in the right direction.
But as for Bell all I can say is that what I see through my glasses is a job well done and invariably the team goes better when he comes in. I think you can grasp it better at the ground live rather than on the tv set...what he does and the pressure he applies. We often just see on the ball on the tv set. And the main thing is that a coach of the pedigree of Longmire values what he brings...that's enough for me. And keeps me happy when he gets selectedComment
-
I've often meant to look into it, but we'd have to define "better". Presumably one measure is simply playing more games for a second or subsequent club than the first, though lots of factors could affect that measure.
Anyway, mental note for a fun stats project some time.Comment
Comment