Schnieder and Dempster off to Moorabbin

[TheGrimReaper]

- what a silly thing to complain about. Plenty of fans will be happy to lose either of them if the team improves.

What happens if we don't and they do?

[hammo]

I told her, that the fans don't want to lose Schneider or Buchanan.

What makes you think your view is represetative of most fans?

[cruiser]

- what a silly thing to complain about. Plenty of fans will be happy to lose either of them if the team improves.

It's not silly. People are entitled to their views, to express their views and to lobby in favour of their view if they think that it might make a difference. It was just this type of action that saw Roos made coach of Sydney instead of Wallace - did you think that was silly?

[TheGrimReaper]

It's not silly. People are entitled to their views, to express their views and to lobby in favour of their view if they think that it might make a difference. It was just this type of action that saw Roos made coach of Sydney instead of Wallace - did you think that was silly?

Thank you mate.

[TheGrimReaper]

What makes you think your view is represetative of most fans?

Sorry then, let's just trade two good premiership players maybe 4 for a dud player from St.Kilda and a draft pick! Maybe instead of the 2nd round draft pick, we should be happy with a 3rd round draft pick for Schneider, Buchanan and Dempster? Would you be happy with that?

[swantastic]

It's not silly. People are entitled to their views, to express their views and to lobby in favour of their view if they think that it might make a difference. It was just this type of action that saw Roos made coach of Sydney instead of Wallace - did you think that was silly?

Very good points cruiser.

[TheGrimReaper]

It is silly if you say "the fans don't want to lose Schneider or Buchanan" rather than saying it is you who doesn't want to lose them.

Most don't want to lose them. If you think you're in the majority then you're the one that's being silly.

[Sanecow]

I complained about the sausage rolls.

[TheGrimReaper]

I complained about the sausage rolls.

Leigh Fisher wouldnt be kicking as many sausage rolls for us than Schneider would.

[swantastic]

I complained about the sausage rolls.

why?because they didnt come with sauce.

[Glenn]

If losing either or means a improved side in 2008 wonder if you would still want them in the side.
If it doesn't work out so be it, either way neither have been traded as yet so go take some Bex and have a nice lye down.

[swantastic]

If losing either or means a improved side in 2008 wonder if you would still want them in the side.
If it doesn't work out so be it, either way neither have been traded as yet so go take some Bex and have a nice lye down.

Now i know your old Glenn

[hammo]

Most don't want to lose them. If you think you're in the majority then you're the one that's being silly.

I am sure most Swans fans are interested in building a team to win our next premiership, regardless of who's wearing the #13, #24 etc. At some point you need to have some faith that Roos and Ireland know what they're doing.

[TheGrimReaper]

In this thread 25 say trade and 5 say don't (and 3 rant about Hall). A fairly large majority on RWO in favour of a good trade if it can be done.

Yeah a good trade, like maybe for someone like Jared Brennan perhaps.

But not duds like Leigh Fisher, who has had hamstring problems in the past according to the Saints supporters on bigfooty. Fisher for Schneider and Dempster is not fair.

[TheGrimReaper]

I am sure most Swans fans are interested in building a team to win our next premiership, regardless of who's wearing the #13, #24 etc. At some point you need to have some faith that Roos and Ireland know what they're doing.

I do have faith, but I would rather get rid of players like Benny Mathews and Jared Crouch rather than Adam Schneider or Amon Buchanan.