Schnieder and Dempster off to Moorabbin

[swantastic]

In this thread 25 say trade and 5 say don't (and 3 rant about Hall). A large majority on RWO in favour of a good trade if it can be done.

Maybe so but most people on here are from NSW and we(Victorians) all know they no nothing about football

[TheGrimReaper]

Maybe so but most people on here are from NSW and we(Victorians) all know they no nothing about football

God bless Victoria.

[hammo]

Yeah a good trade, like maybe for someone like Jared Brennan perhaps.

But not duds like Leigh Fisher, who has had hamstring problems in the past according to the Saints supporters on bigfooty. Fisher for Schneider and Dempster is not fair.

I told her, that the fans don't want to lose Schneider or Buchanan.

So which one is it?

[TheGrimReaper]

So which one is it?

You know my preffered option is to keep Schneider and Buchanan so don't try and twist my bloody words around.

[hammo]

You know my preffered option is to keep Schneider and Buchanan so don't try and twist my bloody words around.

I just quoted what you said

[TheGrimReaper]

I think you've tied yourself in knots - no need for twisting from anyone else!


True - they still clap points!

I'm not the one tied up in knots mate, I want to keep Schneider.

[Margie]

In this thread 25 say trade and 5 say don't (and 3 rant about Hall). A large majority on RWO in favour of a good trade if it can be done.

Only a minority of Swans fans frequent RWO.

[TheGrimReaper]

Unless there is "a good trade".


Yes, and they may not even be a good cross section. However, we don't know how many support the trade and how many don't, despite Footylover1's view that most don't, so that poll was the closest indication we have.

It has to be "really" great. But not for bloody duds like Leigh Fisher. Who the hell has heard of him?

You all know my opinion, and thats to keep them.

[TheGrimReaper]

Unless there is "a good trade".


True and they may not even be a good cross section. However, we don't know how many support the trade and how many don't, despite Footylover1's view that most don't, so that poll was the closest indication we have.

I still can't believe you think you're in the majority.

[goswannie14]

I told her, that the fans don't want to lose Schneider or Buchanan.

You don't speak for me on that, you would be better speaking for yourself than making rash generalisations about what others think.

[swantastic]

So all up, we get Mattner and Fisher (not exactly world beaters) and 26 for the loss of Schnieder, Dempster and 28.

What is Roos thinking?

I really rate Dempster and I think he will be a great pick up for the Saints. I for one will miss him if this is true.

No,Schneider + pick#11 to saints..in return they give us Picks # 9 and 28.

[TheGrimReaper]

You don't speak for me on that, you would be better speaking for yourself than making rash generalisations about what others think.

Another one who wants a dud like Fisher than to keep Schneider. Bravo!!!

[swantastic]

True - they still clap points!

and still yell out "oh its into touch" or "Referee"

[TheGrimReaper]

Why do you think you are?

Do you really want Leigh Fisher?

[Triple B]

Maybe so but most people on here are from NSW and we(Victorians) all know they no nothing about football

True - they still clap points!

and still yell out "oh its into touch" or "Referee"

Grow up you lot.

It's bad enough having to endure the misconception that all Sydney based fans know SFA about AFL from knuckleheads from other clubs.

Do we really need to endure the same tripe from our own, wink emoticons or not ??