Is Hall finished?

[big bear]

Not our worst last week. I hope he will improve and a big help towards this would be faster and better delivery to him. Still an imposing figure who tends to attract the opposition number one defender.

Go BBB and the swannies.

[big bear]

But it's not as good as cash.

The real reason for Hall's performance is that he is jealous of Adam Goodes. There's Adam going out with Laura Csortan, totally stuffed by the time he plays (using words carefully here) on the field and poor old Bazza with a melon that only his Mother would love.

It would be tough. I know this because I'm an expert on RWO and I categorically know that the Swans are finished for this year!
They lost last week.

Richmond will play in the GF against either Dorks or Dogs and win it for Terry!

So there!!!!

What are you on. I hope you are only joking.

[DeadlyAkkuret]

What are you on. I hope you are only joking.

I hope you're only joking.

[Triple B]

Is it too late to vote ????

[Zlatorog]

I'm not changing my vote as yet until I see him consistently perform like yesterday for next 6-7 games.

[Mike_B]

I'm not changing my vote as yet until I see him consistently perform like yesterday for next 6-7 games.

Still waiting to make up my mind too. Yesterday definitely had a lot of positives, but now he needs to do the same in night games!

[Robbo]

One game means very little in the grand scheme of things. Lets see if he can play at that level over an extended period.

[swantastic]

Still waiting to make up my mind too. Yesterday definitely had a lot of positives, but now he needs to do the same in night games!

I dont care about the night games just as long as he plays like that in all the day games i'll be happy.

[swansrule100]

i want to see him kick goals and create play when the chips are down, not when we are smashing a team over the park.

But yesterday has to give him a lot of confidence

[Robbo]

i want to see him kick goals and create play when the chips are down, not when we are smashing a team over the park.

Well the chips were down tonight, and Hall was awful.

Does everyone now agree that the man is finished?

[573v30]

I'll give him at least one more week...

[pig@fullforward]

since hall had a bad first game back i guess we had better get rid of goodes as well since he's had a bad few weeks! seems like everyone loves players when they are good then then very next week wants to ship them off to some remote island!

[Robbo]

It's not just his performance I'm worried about.

It's his mindset aswell. He's lost the plot.

[NMWBloods]

Hall will never recapture his 2006 and prior form. He lost that in the GF and never recaptured it in 2007, partly due to injury and partly due to rule changes. Just struggling to have an impact against decent teams, partly his own fault and partly due to crap delivery.

He can still be effective for us but we need to be smarter - better delivery, different forward plans, and move him around.

[swantastic]

He's too busy thinking about boxing,maybe it is time for the tap on the shoulder.