Is Hall finished?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • timthefish
    Regular in the Side
    • Sep 2003
    • 940

    #76
    no
    then again, i think it would be worth trying 15-16 players on field so what would i know

    Comment

    • Legs Akimbo
      Grand Poobah
      • Apr 2005
      • 2809

      #77
      Originally posted by pig@fullforward
      since hall had a bad first game back i guess we had better get rid of goodes as well since he's had a bad few weeks! seems like everyone loves players when they are good then then very next week wants to ship them off to some remote island!
      I don't want him to be washed up, but a dispassionate appraisal of his last 2 years of footy leaves me to believe (i) he is washed up and (ii) we play better without him because we are less one-dimensional. What they want to do is kick it to him when he is in position and to others when he is not. But it is just not happening. the mid fielders are are too Hall conscious and just tend to kick to him and hope. But he has lost a yard of pace, he was never a great contested mark and seldom takes any now (at all), and his kicking is only average. So, what is left?

      And yes, some of the delivery is crap, but good players make @@@@ into strawberry jam. Barry Hall no longer has that capacity.

      Considering where he is at and where the team is at, some hard questions need to be asked at the end of the year.
      He had observed that people who did lie were, on the whole, more resourceful and ambitious and successful than people who did not lie.

      Comment

      • sprite
        Regular in the Side
        • Jan 2003
        • 813

        #78
        Let's see how he goes in couple of day games - he is usually pretty average in night games.

        BTW what were the conditions like - no tv and SEN commentary except foe Andrew Thompson was biased rubbish.
        sprite

        Comment

        • Plugger46
          Senior Player
          • Apr 2003
          • 3674

          #79
          I think this question has been answered... Played a blinder on the weekend, after two solid performances.

          Plenty to offer.
          Bloods

          "Lockett is the best of all time" - Robert Harvey, Darrel Baldock, Nathan Burke, Kevin Bartlett, Bob Skilton

          Comment

          • Xie Shan
            Senior Player
            • Jan 2003
            • 2929

            #80
            Originally posted by Plugger46
            I think this question has been answered... Played a blinder on the weekend, after two solid performances.

            Plenty to offer.
            Yes, I had my doubts about how much he still had to offer us but full credit to him, he's been solid the past few weeks.

            Comment

            • Lohengrin
              On the Rookie List
              • Jul 2008
              • 641

              #81
              Let's see how he goes against good opposition first.

              Comment

              • Xie Shan
                Senior Player
                • Jan 2003
                • 2929

                #82
                Originally posted by Lohengrin
                Let's see how he goes against good opposition first.
                Um...Geelong? Unless you were referring to Scarlett being absent...

                Comment

                • Lohengrin
                  On the Rookie List
                  • Jul 2008
                  • 641

                  #83
                  Originally posted by Xie Shan
                  Um...Geelong? Unless you were referring to Scarlett being absent...
                  Um... Harry Taylor!

                  Bomber Thompson was quite comfortable to leave Taylor there to get comprehensively beaten as it was a good learning experience for him and Geelong were never in any danger of losing.

                  Comment

                  • TheGrimReaper
                    Suspended by the MRP
                    • Sep 2007
                    • 2203

                    #84
                    Hall is far from finished. Hopefully has a big season next year, to prove his critics wrong.

                    Comment

                    • Legs Akimbo
                      Grand Poobah
                      • Apr 2005
                      • 2809

                      #85
                      His improvement over the last two rounds is perhaps as much to do with Goodes moving to FF and his move further afield. I agree he has played well in the last few games, but feel that his value to the team next year is dependent on playing as a CHF not a FF.
                      He had observed that people who did lie were, on the whole, more resourceful and ambitious and successful than people who did not lie.

                      Comment

                      • Plugger46
                        Senior Player
                        • Apr 2003
                        • 3674

                        #86
                        Originally posted by Legs Akimbo
                        His improvement over the last two rounds is perhaps as much to do with Goodes moving to FF and his move further afield. I agree he has played well in the last few games, but feel that his value to the team next year is dependent on playing as a CHF not a FF.
                        Agree but he has always played his best footy at CHF in my opinion, so nothing has changed.

                        Probably not the player he was, but 'finished' was premature and ridiculous.

                        People forgot how well he had played in some of the games, prior to the Staker incident.
                        Bloods

                        "Lockett is the best of all time" - Robert Harvey, Darrel Baldock, Nathan Burke, Kevin Bartlett, Bob Skilton

                        Comment

                        • ScottH
                          It's Goodes to cheer!!
                          • Sep 2003
                          • 23665

                          #87
                          I don't thin khe is finished, I think there are plenty more blondes out there for him.

                          Comment

                          • DST
                            The voice of reason!
                            • Jan 2003
                            • 2705

                            #88
                            When he has actually played this year he has looked very good.

                            No surprise that he struggled between his two enforced holidays and for a couple of weeks afterwards as he came back.

                            When you are over 30, it takes longer to readjust to the tempo of things.

                            DST
                            "Looking forward to a rebuilt, new, fast and exciting Swans model in 2010"

                            Comment

                            • Lucky Knickers
                              Fandom of Fabulousness
                              • Oct 2003
                              • 4220

                              #89
                              Originally posted by DST
                              When you are over 30, it takes longer to readjust to the tempo of things.
                              I've noticed that too.
                              As our remaining games are night time I was glad to see Baz sticking marks.

                              Comment

                              • Robbo
                                On the Rookie List
                                • May 2007
                                • 2946

                                #90
                                He played well on Saturday, but the reality is he was opposed to a first year player.

                                He wouldn't of got a kick on Scarlett.

                                Comment

                                Working...