Only cos the ball bounced his way. Could just have easily been Goodes' ball, in which case Surjan would be up for a week. It wasn't as if Surjan was already there when Goodes slid. The ball was in dispute, both players slid in, but because Goodes didn't come up with the ball, he was punished. Just doesn't make logical sense.
Goodesy - One Week
Collapse
X
-
I am so disappointed that we won't be able to honour Adam on Sunday at the SCG. According to a press report tonight "The Swans were preparing to fly the dual Brownlow Medal winner's family to Sydney for the historic game against North Melbourne." I hope they now wait until the night match at SCG on 5 May to celebrate Goodes.Comment
-
Driver of the Dan Hannebery bandwagon....all aboard. 4th April 09Comment
-
There goes my Charlie.
I'm going back to the foetal position now.Wild speculation, unsubstantiated rumours, silly jokes and opposition delight in another's failures is what makes an internet forum fun.
Blessed are the cracked for they are the ones who let in the light.Comment
-
The good old insufficient force is the get out of jail card for some players. A bit like attempting to strike; the old lesser offence. That elbow on Pavlich was there for the world to see. Probably the most bewildering decision by a jury that I can recall.Comment
-
Talking of elbows to the head, how did JPod get away with one on Sunday, without it even being looked at by the MRP??
It was pretty clear on TV, then the commentators somehow managed to @@@@ it up and completely miss the flying elbow, taking young Harper to task for remonstrating with JPod 'for no reason' when the replay started from when Harper retaliated, seconds after copping an elbow...Driver of the Dan Hannebery bandwagon....all aboard. 4th April 09Comment
-
TBh sliding in with knees is seen as a thuggish act and reverts back to the bad old days which i think is why the commentators made a point about it. It's stupid and well Goodsey should have known better. I think if he didn't do in the NAB cup then he would have got off.
Oh well at least now opposition fans can't boo him and call him protected. If anything they should focus their energy on Judd who got off and won the charlie after trying to blind someone.
If we want to carry on about this business of using the knees then lets take it out of marking contests. More players have been badly injured over the years in this way. IIRC Sam Newman lost a kidney in this way and in more recent times Tom Lonergan. On a weekly basis you see players holding their backs after a player "gets a ride" on their backs.Comment
-
I tweeted FoxFooty and asked them to get David King's assessment of Goodes' act of sliding. Not surprisingly, they haven't asked him yet...Driver of the Dan Hannebery bandwagon....all aboard. 4th April 09Comment
-
Yeah , so unfair , if only they'd looked at it from a 37.5 degree angle on that fortieth slow-mo replay , yada yada yada.
Prior to being formally wiped out , Goodes - though he had done some great things in all three games - was hardly in Brownlow form.
And if we are to be considered a serious threat , then we should be able to cope with the loss of one player , however brilliant.
The folks I feel sorry for , are the travelling North fans ,who miss out on seeing him play (I recall being disappointed at not seeing Cyril Rioli play up here a couple of seasons back , due to a suspension).
So , Gooodsey's replacement - grab your chance and play your guts out !Comment
-
Bloods
"Lockett is the best of all time" - Robert Harvey, Darrel Baldock, Nathan Burke, Kevin Bartlett, Bob SkiltonComment
-
Comment
Comment