List changes and trade bait
Collapse
X
-
Comment
-
Mal going dents our ability to win the flag next year, but in the overall scheme of things, getting compensation (draft pick) for a 30 year old player while he still has currency is a pragmatic outcome from a long time point of view.
However between 2014 and 2015, our nemisis has added a free agent in Frawley, while we have lost one in Malceski.
Cant wait to start tapping into some of these GWS young guns, eager for instant success, without moving city.Comment
-
ACL is the Association for Computational Linguistics (ACL Home Page | Association for Computational Linguistics), isn't it?Comment
-
So, after a couple of big trading years do you think the club is going for consolidation this time? That, even with the drafted improvements to Port and Hawks, another year of playing the current Swans team (less Mal) gives us a shot at 2015?Comment
-
I believe we will be bigger and better next year and still think us, Hawks and Port will be far and away the best teams.Comment
-
We need improvement from younger players to hold our ground but it is not unreasonable to expect some. Every club continuously relies on new players to come through to replace those whose performances drop off due to age (or leaving). In 2014 we had Parker and Cunningham who exceeded most people's expectations. I thought some of our improvement might come from Parker but not quite to the extent he delivered. Of course, we can't necessarily expect he can maintain that level. But if a Mitchell comes in and adds something, and we get someone emerge from almost nowhere to play a role as Cunningham did, there is no reason we can't improve enough in some areas to offset the impact of Malceski's departure.
I also think that some of our established "stars" are capable of more than they delivered in 2014. Our 2013 AA trio of McVeigh, Jack and Hanners, in particular, were a little down in 2014 compared to 2013.Comment
-
Re the Biggs situation I speculate it means that Heeney is seen as the better option and the club has not given Biggs any comfort.There's not much difference in size between the two and both can play wing or HBF but Heeney is more versatile and probably physically stronger as well having x factor. Also a long term local proposition not subject to a "go home" factor.
The half back line also requires real line breakers to have a successful team and whilst being highly serviceable it may be this x factor that is lacking for Biggs in the club's view.We have them where we want them, everything is going according to plan!Comment
-
the only Swans left field rumour that i have heard so far is
Sydney are sniffing around Ryan Schoenmakers but not sure what they could offer and i would have thought melb would try hard to get Ryan across to them ASAP??
Ryan Schoenmakers - hawthornfc.com.au
Im just wondering if any truth given he will be second fiddle to Gibson, Lake and Frawley
ive googled a bit since hearing the rumours the last week or so and it appears he wants to stay ????
No Cookies | Herald Sun"be tough, only when it gets tough"
Comment
-
It's very hard to live in a studio apartment in San Jose with a man who's learning to play violin. That's what she told the police when she handed them the empty revolver.
The Scarlatti Tilt - Richard BrautiganComment
-
Re the Biggs situation I speculate it means that Heeney is seen as the better option and the club has not given Biggs any comfort.There's not much difference in size between the two and both can play wing or HBF but Heeney is more versatile and probably physically stronger as well having x factor. Also a long term local proposition not subject to a "go home" factor.
The half back line also requires real line breakers to have a successful team and whilst being highly serviceable it may be this x factor that is lacking for Biggs in the club's view.
In terms of those to play off the half-back flank, in addition to the McVeigh option we have Rohan, Jones, Marsh. Sure, they are all unproven but so is Biggs essentially. We could also move Rampe to play more of a rebounding role, and have Laidler or Reid play predominantly defensive role. Or someone like X might graduate to that "3rd tall defender" role, similar to how Johnson started out in the team. Or a miracle might happen and we might get Johnson himself back. So there are plenty of ways the defence might line up, without or without Biggs.Comment
-
Comment
-
New Crows coach is Phil Walsh, an assistant coach from Port. So Stewie Dew is not off to Adelaide.
Laughed when I read that someone from Port expressed surprise about this appointment, noting that Walsh had "never spoken glowingly of the Crows". It's a "cat among the pigeons" appointment in the footy politics of Adelaide.Comment
-
the only Swans left field rumour that i have heard so far is
Sydney are sniffing around Ryan Schoenmakers but not sure what they could offer and i would have thought melb would try hard to get Ryan across to them ASAP??
Ryan Schoenmakers - hawthornfc.com.au
Im just wondering if any truth given he will be second fiddle to Gibson, Lake and Frawley
ive googled a bit since hearing the rumours the last week or so and it appears he wants to stay ????
No Cookies | Herald Sun"You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."Comment
Comment