A mate of mine had the following letter printed in the SMH yesterday. It was voted best letter of the day. And, he's a Richmond supporter.
AFL too deluded to take a good, hard look at itself
I am an equally passionate fan of Aussie rules and rugby league, the two great people's games of Australia. However, the different attitudes revealed this season by the respective codes' administrators and fans with regard to a very important aspect of their cultures cannot avoid comparison.
We've just witnessed a thrilling NRL grand final played between two brilliantly creative and adventurous teams, each captained by Aboriginal greats. This followed the NRL bestowing its highest award, the Dally M medal, on one of those skippers, Jonathan Thurston, who was then also awarded the grand final best and fairest medal. Thurston is widely revered throughout the rugby league world, and his opposing skipper, Justin Hodges, is also widely respected. Most fans at the stadium stayed to witness Thurston lifting the trophy aloft out of respect for this Indigenous legend.
Compare this to the disgraceful reception AFL Aboriginal champion Adam Goodes has received at AFL stadiums this season. This legend of the game was even booed loudly by opposition fans when he kicked the football for the final time in his illustrious career, and this when the opposition already had the game in the bag.
It was a dismal, disillusioning and deeply disappointing scene. For Goodes to then (understandably) avoid the retiring players' parade before the AFL grand final, for fear of being booed by fans of both combatants, was a shameful end to what has been a lamentable season for the AFL in many ways.
AFL enjoys portraying its game and fans as more diverse and more sophisticated than rugby league's. But is this not simply a major, self-evident, delusion? Perhaps it's also a delusion that serves to prevent the AFL from taking a necessary good hard look at itself?
AFL too deluded to take a good, hard look at itself
I am an equally passionate fan of Aussie rules and rugby league, the two great people's games of Australia. However, the different attitudes revealed this season by the respective codes' administrators and fans with regard to a very important aspect of their cultures cannot avoid comparison.
We've just witnessed a thrilling NRL grand final played between two brilliantly creative and adventurous teams, each captained by Aboriginal greats. This followed the NRL bestowing its highest award, the Dally M medal, on one of those skippers, Jonathan Thurston, who was then also awarded the grand final best and fairest medal. Thurston is widely revered throughout the rugby league world, and his opposing skipper, Justin Hodges, is also widely respected. Most fans at the stadium stayed to witness Thurston lifting the trophy aloft out of respect for this Indigenous legend.
Compare this to the disgraceful reception AFL Aboriginal champion Adam Goodes has received at AFL stadiums this season. This legend of the game was even booed loudly by opposition fans when he kicked the football for the final time in his illustrious career, and this when the opposition already had the game in the bag.
It was a dismal, disillusioning and deeply disappointing scene. For Goodes to then (understandably) avoid the retiring players' parade before the AFL grand final, for fear of being booed by fans of both combatants, was a shameful end to what has been a lamentable season for the AFL in many ways.
AFL enjoys portraying its game and fans as more diverse and more sophisticated than rugby league's. But is this not simply a major, self-evident, delusion? Perhaps it's also a delusion that serves to prevent the AFL from taking a necessary good hard look at itself?
Comment