1st QF Swans v Giants

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Meg
    Go Swannies!
    Site Admin
    • Aug 2011
    • 4828

    As discussed earlier in this thread if MRP impose a sanction on Johnson it may well have a one match bad record loading.

    Comment

    • Danzar
      I'm doing ok right now, thanks
      • Jun 2006
      • 2027

      Niall on Fox suggested that Stevie J's prior record won't come into play. I'm not sure why that is. Niall's right in that his 2014 suspension is just outside the two years (it was really early in the season). But doesn't this count? Home | Live Scores & Latest News | Fox Sports
      Captain, I am detecting large quantities of win in this sector

      Comment

      • Velour&Ruffles
        Regular in the Side
        • Jun 2006
        • 896

        Originally posted by stevoswan
        I wouldn't question Gerard Whatley's motives, he might be a Cat fan, but he has integrity......
        No he doesn't. He's as partisan as Dermie. The fact he doesn't sound like a bogan just obscures it a bit.
        My opinion is objective truth in its purest form

        Comment

        • Wardy
          The old Boiler!
          • Sep 2003
          • 6676

          So now we know that Tippet has a fractured jaw - where does that put thug Mumford with the MRP???
          I used to be indecisive, but now I'm not so sure..................
          Chickens drink - but they don't pee!
          AGE IS ONLY IMPORTANT FOR TWO THINGS - WINE & CHEESE!

          Comment

          • Danzar
            I'm doing ok right now, thanks
            • Jun 2006
            • 2027

            Originally posted by Wardy
            So now we know that Tippet has a fractured jaw - where does that put thug Mumford with the MRP???
            It may not have been from the sling tackle. Could have been the earlier accidental knee. Depends on the medical report I guess.
            Captain, I am detecting large quantities of win in this sector

            Comment

            • Meg
              Go Swannies!
              Site Admin
              • Aug 2011
              • 4828

              Originally posted by Danzar
              It may not have been from the sling tackle. Could have been the earlier accidental knee. Depends on the medical report I guess.
              That's certainly what GWS will argue.

              Comment

              • Velour&Ruffles
                Regular in the Side
                • Jun 2006
                • 896

                Originally posted by mcs
                Haha I completely agree goswannies - we should so no favours to the plastics. Its not like any other club would do us a favour in the same circumstance. As much as I hope the plastics don't win the flag, it would at least be great to see Johnson the grub have to watch if from the sidelines.
                Yes, he acted like such a complete tool yesterday that I'd get almost as much pleasure from him missing a GWS flag through suspension as I would from a Swans' flag. OK, not nearly as much but it would certainly be enjoyable.

                As for Mummy, when you look at the video he was holding Tippet's arm so that he had no way of protecting himself from the impact. Pinning the arms when slinging used to be one of the factors taken into account. The thinking was that if you deny the player the opportunity to protect themselves you take responsibility for the consequences. It will be interesting to see whether there has been a change in interpretation now that the single most important player to the fortunes of GWS will miss the grand final if past interpretations are applied. Call me a cynic, but I'm tipping a change of interpretation.
                My opinion is objective truth in its purest form

                Comment

                • Faunac8
                  Senior Player
                  • Mar 2014
                  • 1548

                  Originally posted by Wardy
                  So now we know that Tippet has a fractured jaw - where does that put thug Mumford with the MRP???
                  Course when he was a Swan he was an enforcer not a thug ????

                  Comment

                  • Velour&Ruffles
                    Regular in the Side
                    • Jun 2006
                    • 896

                    Originally posted by Faunac8
                    Course when he was a Swan he was an enforcer not a thug ??
                    No, when he was a Swan he was suspended for sling tackling Gary Ablett. It was the first sling tackle suspension ever, because it happened BEFORE there was actually a rule against it. Again, let's just see how the rules are applied now that the single most critical player to the fortunes of Frankenstein's Monster may miss if past interpretations are applied. As I said above, I'm smelling a change of interpretations in the wind.
                    My opinion is objective truth in its purest form

                    Comment

                    • annew
                      Senior Player
                      • Mar 2006
                      • 2164

                      Originally posted by Velour&Ruffles
                      No, when he was a Swan he was suspended for sling tackling Gary Ablett. It was the first sling tackle suspejnsion ever, because it happened BEFORE there was actually a rule against it. Again, let's just see how the rules are applied now that the single most critical player to the fortunes of Frankenstein's Monster may miss if past interpretations are applied. As I said above, I'm smelling a change of interpretations in the wind.
                      Agree with what you say totally. Paul Roos on Fox last night brought up the incident with Mumford when at the swans and implied he should be suspended for this one by current rules as should Stevie J. Needless to say the Eddie headed other panel members disagreed.

                      Comment

                      • Velour&Ruffles
                        Regular in the Side
                        • Jun 2006
                        • 896

                        Originally posted by annew
                        Agree with what you say totally. Paul Roos on Fox last night brought up the incident with Mumford when at the swans and implied he should be suspended for this one by current rules as should Stevie J. Needless to say the Eddie headed other panel members disagreed.
                        Wow, there's a shock.
                        My opinion is objective truth in its purest form

                        Comment

                        • stevoswan
                          Veterans List
                          • Sep 2014
                          • 8545

                          Originally posted by 56-14
                          Seems you didn't listen to him when we flogged Cats at the SCG by about 100 points a couple of years back.
                          Biggest pay-out I've ever heard against Swans (Franklin, Tippett, COLA)
                          Integrity!
                          Missed that....oh well, that's disappoints me a bit. Loved that game though.

                          Comment

                          • stevoswan
                            Veterans List
                            • Sep 2014
                            • 8545

                            Originally posted by Danzar
                            It may not have been from the sling tackle. Could have been the earlier accidental knee. Depends on the medical report I guess.
                            Channel 7 news earlier reported that the jaw injury was from the previous incident, not the sling tackle. He still whacked his head though, arms pinned, but who'd be surprised if he only gets one or even off?

                            Comment

                            • Meg
                              Go Swannies!
                              Site Admin
                              • Aug 2011
                              • 4828

                              Originally posted by annew
                              Agree with what you say totally. Paul Roos on Fox last night brought up the incident with Mumford when at the swans and implied he should be suspended for this one by current rules as should Stevie J. Needless to say the Eddie headed other panel members disagreed.
                              Anne, what reasons did the other panel members give for arguing suspensions should not be applied - do you recall?

                              Comment

                              • dejavoodoo44
                                Veterans List
                                • Apr 2015
                                • 8497

                                Originally posted by stevoswan
                                Channel 7 news earlier reported that the jaw injury was from the previous incident, not the sling tackle. He still whacked his head though, arms pinned, but who'd be surprised if he only gets one or even off?
                                Yes, I found it a bit bizarre for a while now, that the Tribunal seems to pay more notice to injury, rather than intent. That is, they seem to judge more harshly, say, someone who accidentally breaks an opponents jaw, than someone who attempts to break a jaw, but fails in the attempt.

                                Comment

                                Working...