Match Day SEMI FINAL Geelong v Sydney MCG 7.50pm Friday 15 September

[Agent 86]

Why are they booing buddy?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Merdo5555]

Unacceptable performance. We sack half the team or the coach. I say the coach. I can stand losing but getting smashed by a team we demolished at there home ground a few weeks ago is disgraceful.

Does anyone really think we can win another premiership with Longmire? He's done and it's time to say thanks and move on.

It's not his fault there are individual errors but it is his fault we are dreadul.

[MattW]

It's silly to even bother talking about selection mistakes when our best players are having such poor games. Kennedy, Parker, Buddy and Rampe all getting hammered, so it's hard to blame the bottom six. It's just one of those nights. It happens. Console yourselves by thinking: "Oh well, we probably would have lost to Adelaide anyway."

I disagree. The non-selection of Melican was arrogant and disrespectful - two tall defenders against Geelong? The team hasn't been well prepared, and the poor selection is an example of it.

[Daisi]

Honestly no idea why they're booing buddy - I agree we've been put coached - putting Dangerfield in the forward line was a smart move and longmuir didn't have an answer

[i'm-uninformed2]

One or two times every year the Swans don't just lose, they have a stinker.

When it happens, the midfield goes missing as a collective, other sides seem to have a permanent spare, Buddy goes absent, our leaders are down, are bottom six are beyond crap, we look dysfunctional and disorganised, and the coaching group is outsmarted. All at once.

It's a complete breakdown mentally, tactically, and skills wise.

We don't just stink when we do. We utterly stink.

[Merdo5555]

We always play poorly when we are favorites. Given the trend why hasn't the coach addressed this? We have consistent coaching failures when we are favorites and/or the opposition play a kick and mark game.

Earlier I heard that we would be quiet at the trade table. If we are serious about winning heads must roll, since they will be too gutless to sack the coach under-performing players must go (and gee there are a few to choose from!)

[waswan]

I disagree. The non-selection of Melican was arrogant and disrespectful - two tall defenders against Geelong? The team hasn't been well prepared, and the poor selection is an example of it.

Totally agree rohan has never done anything behind the centre line and reid is a dangerous fwd that needed to keep henderson accountable
dumb as dumb

[Merdo5555]

On a positive night the Tippet thread is going to explode with comments about how we may have won if he played.

[snajik]

It's a mugs game......he'll learn, maybe.

pity the poor way more deserving charity that could have had his money instead.

[Jeynez]

I disagree. The non-selection of Melican was arrogant and disrespectful - two tall defenders against Geelong? The team hasn't been well prepared, and the poor selection is an example of it.

Our backline isn't why we're losing though

[Scottee]

One or two times every year the Swans don't just lose, they have a stinker.

When it happens, the midfield goes missing as a collective, other sides seem to have a permanent spare, Buddy goes absent, our leaders are down, are bottom six are beyond crap, we look dysfunctional and disorganised, and the coaching group is outsmarted. All at once.

It's a complete breakdown mentally, tactically, and skills wise.

We don't just stink when we do. We utterly stink.

Yes, and it always seems to be a high pressure final.

Sent from my SM-T805Y using Tapatalk

[stevoswan]

One or two times every year the Swans don't just lose, they have a stinker.

When it happens, the midfield goes missing as a collective, other sides seem to have a permanent spare, Buddy goes absent, our leaders are down, are bottom six are beyond crap, we look dysfunctional and disorganised, and the coaching group is outsmarted. All at once.

It's a complete breakdown mentally, tactically, and skills wise.

We don't just stink when we do. We utterly stink.

+1 .....and it begs the question......WHY?????

[MattW]

Our backline isn't why we're losing though

I didn't say that it was. Ludwig's comment was that it was 'silly to even both talking about selection'. I think it's relevant.

[Agent 86]

Our bottom 6 only marginally worse than 2nd bottom 6. Nothing at all to take from this game. A totally abysmal end to the year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Scottee]

We are crap in the wet and we picked a dry weather side.Not smart.

Sent from my SM-T805Y using Tapatalk