#AFL Round 20 Weekly Discussion Thread

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • barry
    Veterans List
    • Jan 2003
    • 8499

    #16
    They weren't icing greens legs so I would say precautionary. Dawson would be a big loss, and deludio is only selected on reputation so no loss.

    Comment

    • Nico
      Veterans List
      • Jan 2003
      • 11355

      #17
      Originally posted by neilfws
      Reckon Ablett would have nailed that every day in his prime

      Good Friday game, enjoyable as a neutral.
      Getting caught a lot is Gazza. He looks to have slowed up appreciably.
      http://www.nostalgiamusic.co.uk/secu...res/srh806.jpg

      Comment

      • liz
        Veteran
        Site Admin
        • Jan 2003
        • 16818

        #18
        Originally posted by Industrial Fan
        Gws have been a different team since Greene came back from injury. Definitely helps our chances that he’s done his hammy.

        If they keep their team on the park they’re definitely one that can challenge for the flag this year.
        He adds to them, for sure, but Kelly's return has been what has made the most difference. They started looking like a good team again before Greene came back.

        Comment

        • Markwebbos
          Veterans List
          • Jul 2016
          • 7186

          #19
          Originally posted by liz
          He adds to them, for sure, but Kelly's return has been what has made the most difference. They started looking like a good team again before Greene came back.
          We'd be a better team if Kelly was running around in our midfield

          Comment

          • cherub
            Warming the Bench
            • May 2010
            • 239

            #20
            Anyone else disgusted with the narrative developing around "poor Andrew Gaff" ? He's probably broken a teenager's jaw behind play, and the commentary is all about how upset and remorseful he is. Not how a teenager is in hospital. Nauseating. Only equalled by the behaviour of the WCE crowd.

            Comment

            • neilfws
              Senior Player
              • Aug 2009
              • 1840

              #21
              Sunday sure was different to Saturday. Suns over the last 2 weeks makes our loss all the more mystifying. I'm increasingly sure that game was more about bad attitude than personnel.

              Just saw the Gaff incident...he is in a world of trouble. Won't be surprised if he's gone for the season. Pretty dumb when your team is a good chance for finals.

              Comment

              • Markwebbos
                Veterans List
                • Jul 2016
                • 7186

                #22
                Originally posted by neilfws
                Sunday sure was different to Saturday. Suns over the last 2 weeks makes our loss all the more mystifying. I'm increasingly sure that game was more about bad attitude than personnel.

                Just saw the Gaff incident...he is in a world of trouble. Won't be surprised if he's gone for the season. Pretty dumb when your team is a good chance for finals.
                And he was one of the front runners for the Brownlow. I wonder if any potential suitor might think twice about paying him $1m plus a year. Young Brayshaw's jaw is broken, allegedly.

                Comment

                • stevoswan
                  Veterans List
                  • Sep 2014
                  • 8578

                  #23
                  Originally posted by stevoswan
                  Probably easier to sum up this rounds games by saying tonight and tomorrow offer competitive games but Sunday, plan to do something else.....
                  I summed that up pretty well!

                  Originally posted by goswannies
                  Some 30% off with your wish. How were your nerves?
                  Ragged in the final few minutes......then really fantastic after the siren went!

                  Comment

                  • 707
                    Veterans List
                    • Aug 2009
                    • 6204

                    #24
                    What a weekend, the AFL were loving it up to last night, five games decided by four points or less, score reviews all ok (ha ha), all good in the AFL world then -

                    Carlton 22 fit men capitulate to 18 fit men with sometimes only 16 on the field, Gold Coast are a shambles yet again then an act of thuggery in the west has a players mother distressed in the stands and him off to hospital for surgery.

                    Just saw the incident, bigger wind up than Bugg, much more damage, 6 weeks minimum, should be more for an ugly act of thuggery regardless of Gaff's clean record. This is a very bad look, the AFL will rightly be concerned.

                    Comment

                    • Mark26
                      Senior Player
                      • Jan 2017
                      • 1535

                      #25
                      Originally posted by Markwebbos
                      And he was one of the front runners for the Brownlow. I wonder if any potential suitor might think twice about paying him $1m plus a year. Young Brayshaw's jaw is broken, allegedly.
                      That is on par with Barry Hall's hit for me. Disgusting. I think if the AFL are going to bring in changes, I would two alterations in this area. Firstly a red card would be appropriate. Immediate send off with no return or substitute. The Eagles should field a team which is one short for the remainder of the match. Secondly, Gaff should not be allowed to play another senior game until Brayshaw is back. The suspension should equal the damage done to the opposition.

                      Comment

                      • Markwebbos
                        Veterans List
                        • Jul 2016
                        • 7186

                        #26
                        Originally posted by Mark26
                        That is on par with Barry Hall's hit for me. Disgusting. I think if the AFL are going to bring in changes, I would two alterations in this area. Firstly a red card would be appropriate. Immediate send off with no return or substitute. The Eagles should field a team which is one short for the remainder of the match. Secondly, Gaff should not be allowed to play another senior game until Brayshaw is back. The suspension should equal the damage done to the opposition.
                        I think Brayshaw should bring GBH charges against him.

                        Comment

                        • 0918330512
                          Senior Player
                          • Sep 2011
                          • 1654

                          #27
                          Originally posted by neilfws
                          Just saw the Gaff incident...he is in a world of trouble. Won't be surprised if he's gone for the season. Pretty dumb when your team is a good chance for finals.
                          Wonder what incited the incident?

                          Comment

                          • neilfws
                            Senior Player
                            • Aug 2009
                            • 1840

                            #28
                            Originally posted by neilfws
                            Just saw the Gaff incident...
                            I wish I had not rewatched it several times, but can at least confirm that it looks worse with repeated viewing. They should throw the book at him and rightly so.

                            Comment

                            • Beerman
                              Regular in the Side
                              • Oct 2010
                              • 823

                              #29
                              Originally posted by Mark26
                              That is on par with Barry Hall's hit for me. Disgusting. I think if the AFL are going to bring in changes, I would two alterations in this area. Firstly a red card would be appropriate. Immediate send off with no return or substitute. The Eagles should field a team which is one short for the remainder of the match. Secondly, Gaff should not be allowed to play another senior game until Brayshaw is back. The suspension should equal the damage done to the opposition.
                              I don't make it quite as bad as Barry Hall's. Gaff and Brayshaw were at least looking and pushing at each other when Gaff lashed out. It is still completely unacceptable on the field though, and I can't see how he would get any less than 6 weeks.

                              The red card/black card question is a very interesting one. How likely is it that it will go horribly wrong and someone will be issued with their marching orders for something innocuous? How much of a penalty is it to be playing a man down? (Clearly not so bad if you're playing Carlton, but I mean against a decent team). How much of a deterrent is it to be down a rotation?

                              Not sure what the answer is, but I have every confidence that the AFL will have some stupid idea as an answer, stuff up the implementation and then claim all the decisions are right.

                              Comment

                              • YvonneH
                                Senior Player
                                • Sep 2011
                                • 1141

                                #30
                                If Tom Mitchell didn't have the Brownlow stitched up before he sure does now, (although I don't think he deserves it after he got off when he was reported).
                                Highly unusual for Gaff as I don't think that is in his nature.

                                Comment

                                Working...