I agree with horse on this one. Blakey is fast, has a great left boot and at an underage level, would turn games when pushed into midfield. His height is irrelevant if he has the skills ( think Cripps and Bont). We are so short on guys who can deliver the ball effectively into the forward line that it's worth trying Blakey upfield.
Changes round III
Collapse
X
-
-
This reflects my view too Melbourne Blood. I worry we will go too tall against Carlton, like I felt we were against the Dogs. While I like the 4 big options, them plus Sinkers seems too much tall timber - and its the pressure that smaller forwards should be able to put on in the forward 50 that really has been noticeably absent.I just don’t think going taller is the answer to the pressure problem we have . In fact I think it would make it worse . I don’t think there are many selection changes available to us currently that will make a great impact , we have to get a major improvement out of the guys out there . Maybe one or two changes ( Clarke needs to be dropped, maybe for jack if he’s ready ) but that would be it I would think . Maybe mccartin comes in but Blakey would have to come out and he has contributed one goal and one assist in each game so far , not sure with our scoring we can afford to lose even that contribution . Mccartin does create a lot of contests and clunks a few though so you never know .
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk"You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."Comment
-
McCartin, Dawson and Thurlow in for Melican, Clarke and O'Riordan.
Will be interesting to see what we do down back!
Sent from my SM-G975F using TapatalkComment
-
In: McCartin Thurlow Dawson
Out: Melican Clarke COR (all omitted)Comment
-
Wow! Very surprised to see Melican dropped. Will Mills now get to play midfield? Possibly not with Melican out too.
Where is Dawson going to play. Surely not FWD? They’ve dropped 2 defenders 0 forwards and brought in 2 forwards 1 defender.Comment
-
Well one “logical” move would be to play Reid as a tall defender.Comment
-
-
Comment
-
Comment
-
Exactly what I was about to post ! Perhaps it’s horses for courses, Carlton has Casboult and McKay as talls ( curnow is out ) so maybe Rampe and Allir are enough to cover those ? Possible regarding horses words through the week that Blakey will move to a wing ?
Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkComment
-
Casboult has come in to replace Curnow. The other tall forward is Mitch McGovernComment
-
McCartin may spend time in defence if needed. Good footy brain.Exactly what I was about to post ! Perhaps it’s horses for courses, Carlton has Casboult and McKay as talls ( curnow is out ) so maybe Rampe and Allir are enough to cover those ? Possible regarding horses words through the week that Blakey will move to a wing ?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
- - - Updated - - -
Dawson needs to be played where he can deliver ball inside 50. Elite kick that we miss apart from Mcveigh. Same with Blakey if possible. Rotate them high and low?Exactly what I was about to post ! Perhaps it’s horses for courses, Carlton has Casboult and McKay as talls ( curnow is out ) so maybe Rampe and Allir are enough to cover those ? Possible regarding horses words through the week that Blakey will move to a wing ?
Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkComment

Comment