Well, the coaches thought Stoddart edged out Stephens in performance for the game. So saying that I preferred Stoddart to Stephens is not that farfetched.
Swans VFL 2023
Collapse
X
-
Coaches votes for the Frankston game.
5 Tom Hickey (SS)
5 Nicholas Shipley (SS)
5 Ryley Stoddart (FRA)
4 Will Fordham (FRA)
4 Dylan Stephens (SS)
4 Jackson Voss (FRA)
2 Josh Butland (FRA)
1 Trent Mynott (FRA)
Which seems quite an odd distribution, with two players getting five votes from one coach and none from the other.
I also noticed that Barry O'Connor was voted BOG for the Giants VFL side on the weekend. When I watched a small bit of their game a few weeks ago, they seemed to be trying him as a big bodied midfielder. Good luck to him, I guess, but I hope it doesn't come back to bite us too much.Comment
-
Stoddart got given 3 by one coach and 2 by the other.
Given other votes, I think Frankston have no votes to our side at all.
So the voting is not really a good reflection of player impact on the day, given it seems our 5 and 4 votes were not added to by the other side.
Doesn’t mean your preference is any less valid, just that the votes is not good supporting data.Comment
-
That bodes badly. But I wonder if that is the coaching. I do not think this coach is an improvement on Jeremy. I am worried we made a huge mistake. Why not get Tadhg to come back? Surely our recruiters can't have gotten it this wrong. All of this year's recruits under 10 disposals and 3 under 5. @@@@.?
Sent from my JAT-L29 using Tapatalk
Sent from my SM-F936B using TapatalkComment
-
VFL Team: Wicks returns to face Williamstown
Although not mentioned in the blurb heralding the return of Wicks, a scan of the team list shows that Mitchell is also slated to return. Maybe they think fans won't notice he was ever missing.Comment
-
Good opportunity to get a close look at our supposed mid-season draft target Oscar McDonald. Plus to see how McAndrew fares against a good ruck in Downie.Comment
-
Amusing comment on Mitchell there Liz, but true! A player each week must be on one of three lists, Seniors, VFL or Injury
MSD target - Oscar McDonald will be in the frame if we think the season is salvageable but, if there's internal thoughts, due to our ongoing injury list, that the season is done we'll pick a player for the future.
We'd want good wins today over Freo and next week over Norf to still be in finals contention. We're currently 13th with shot %Comment
-
Comment
-
Comment
-
Swans VFL playing OK today for a change. Owen gets a free kick from 35 m out and cannot make the distance. We need a serious kicking coach for both seniors and reserves.Comment
-
I’ve liked the look of Howard too. Caused me to look up his name on the team list. Has a bit of composure lacking in so many others.
The loss of Shipley just before quarter time hasn’t helped but given there’s no-one in the team capable of even hitting a short hit-up 15m kick - anywhere on the ground, not just into the forward line - it’s going to be an uphill battle.Comment
-
Gesendet von iPad mit TapatalkComment
Comment