trade week ideas (merged thread)

[swantastic]

Originally posted by NMWBloods
Doyle would be completely useless as full back, and no one in their right mind would have two ruckmen and no rover in the centre square.

I had B1,Kirk,Kennelly in the center thats alright,with Spida to do ruck and F 50 bounces,with jolly to do D50 and be used as extra tall down back.To fill up the spaces.Why would Doyle be usless?

[NMWBloods]

Originally posted by swantastic
I had B1,Kirk,Kennelly in the center thats alright,with Spida to do ruck and F 50 bounces,with jolly to do D50 and be used as extra tall down back.To fill up the spaces.Why would Doyle be usless?

You had Bolton and Kennelly on the wings - not so useful at the centre bounce. Everitt and Jolly in the centre bounce is pointless.

Doyle is too slow and gangly to be a full back.

[Sanecow]

Originally posted by swantastic
Why would Doyle be usless?

Too slow! Plonk the Donk up the other end!

[swantastic]

Originally posted by NMWBloods
You had Bolton and Kennelly on the wings - not so useful at the centre bounce. Everitt and Jolly in the centre bounce is pointless.

Doyle is too slow and gangly to be a full back.

But Monty and Schneider could start around the middle to drag there opponents out of F50,because Davis, Mol,Hall and Rok are still down there.Doyle might be gangly but he could push up abit to drag the FF out of square and it will clog up space.IMO Dustin Fletcher is a little slow and gangly and he does alright .

[NMWBloods]

Originally posted by swantastic
But Monty and Schneider could start around the middle to drag there opponents out of F50,because Davis, Mol,Hall and Rok are still down there.

But they are not in the square. What use is Jolly at the centre square bounce if Everitt is doing the ruck? How can we possibly be competitive with three big ruckman loping around the park at the same time?

Doyle might be gangly but he could push up abit to drag the FF out of square and it will clog up space.IMO Dustin Fletcher is a little slow and gangly and he does alright .

Comparing Doyle to Fletcher is really quite misguided...

[swantastic]

Originally posted by NMWBloods
[B]But they are not in the square. What use is Jolly at the centre square bounce if Everitt is doing the ruck? How can we possibly be competitive with three big ruckman loping around the park at the same time?

Comparing Doyle to Fletcher is really quite misguided...

Alright put one of them on bench.Doyle v Fletcher my brain is still fried from saturday.

[swansrule100]

the only possible way (IMHO) for all three to play in the team presuming we get everitt, is everitt playing forward which he has shown he can and jolly starting ruck and doyle on the bench, maybe jolly could drift forward sometimes or even doyle as well and everitt takes some ruckwork. But it seems like one too many talls to me.

[Jeffers1984]

Can forget about Mal Michael now. Just announced his retirement on SEN.

Thank christ for that.

[Gary]

A tall key back is our greatest immediate need. If they refuse to give Vogels an extended run, then we must be looking hard for a trade. Has Mal Michaels settled down at Brisbane...how old is he?

[swansrule100]

lets get glass then he will never beat hall..


There arent many quality tall backman about and there are none that i can think of that are gonna be available!

[ItsAllGoodes]

Originally posted by Gary
A tall key back is our greatest immediate need. If they refuse to give Vogels an extended run, then we must be looking hard for a trade. Has Mal Michaels settled down at Brisbane...how old is he?

Mal Michaels has announced his retirement

http://ninemsn.sportal.com.au/default.aspx?s=afldisplay&id=89272

[JIM4]

[QUOTE]Originally posted by ItsAllGoodes
[B]Mal Michaels has announced his retirement
= Tim Notting could be a good pick up as he wants to go to another club next year

[JIM4]

[QUOTE]Originally posted by ItsAllGoodes
[B]Mal Michaels has announced his retirement
= Tim Notting could be a good pick up as he wants to go to another club next year

[Sanecow]

Jim, is there something you are trying to say?

[Grant]

Originally posted by Sanecow
Jim, is there something you are trying to say?

Ummmm, i think he is saying Notting wants to go to another club.