Trade target discussion (merged thread)

[Ludwig]

It's too early to say how many spots will be available on our list come draft day, but if we do have a late pick in the ND (which might happen if Dunkley doesn't get drafted by us), I think we should consider taking a shot on Sydney Uni's Tom Young. And if not in the ND, then perhaps as a rookie. I was really impressed by him when our reserves side played them. He just won the NEAFL MVP. He's still only 23. He's a good size and a versatile player. I can see him holding down a 3rd defender type role. He might be a better option for our list than someone like Harry Marsh, and if Harry does get delisted, I would be more inclined to get Young.

The success of the Bulldogs this year has influenced my thinking about where the game is headed. The Bulldogs actually have a rather shallow list and have often played several mediocre or inexperienced players and still managed to play well. Two things that they do a bit differently than other clubs is 1) not worry about losing the hitouts, but still focus on getting the clearance and 2) get the defenders to participate in a hard running drive to the forward line, even if this leaves the defence exposed on the rebound. These tactics make them a difficult team to play against. They do give up a fair number of turnover goals, but nonetheless manage to structure up well when the ball does get turned over, which is something they obviously need to do with the kind of game plan they have.

The loss of Malceski has often been noted as a reason for our lack of defensive rebound this year. I hope we don't lose Jetta, because it will not be easy to replace his combination of pace and foot skills.

Regardless of the trade ban outcome, I would not be chasing a lumbering ruckman. There are always a few players that get delisted by other clubs, like Laidler, that represent good value when at the right club. We have a long history in this regard and this should again be our focus this year.

[jono2707]

I've liked Tom Young when I've seen him this year too - and good on him winning the NEAFL MVP. I certainly think he'd be worth a spot on our list if we can fit him in.

He'd be cheap too. Perhaps a few other teams have noticed him so it'd be good for him (and the NEAFL) if he gets back on a list.

[Pmcc2911]

You would have to think he would be worth a spot on the rookie list.
It would certainly reinforce the idea of the NEAFL being a pathway to the big leagues.

[Dosser]

Just watching the Lions today. Jed Adcock is still 29 and is being delisted by Brisbane. He was an absolute gun hbf not that long ago and still seems to have his smarts. Worth taking a look at, I'd say.

[WauchopeAnalyst]

Yep. Good call. ????

[Mug Punter]

Just watching the Lions today. Jed Adcock is still 29 and is being delisted by Brisbane. He was an absolute gun hbf not that long ago and still seems to have his smarts. Worth taking a look at, I'd say.

Could well be worth a punt for the right price.

If Jetta stays then I don't think we will have a lot of wriggle room cap wise but we may have room for as cheapie. If he leaves then things become a lot more problematic....

[WauchopeAnalyst]

With Bennell being a West Australian both Freo and the Eagles might prefer Bennell over Jetta.

Bennell fits right into the 1990s and 2000s of the Eagles with their substance problems.

And Freo could boo Goodesy and Jetta might then sign a 2 year deal with us.

[Ludwig]

Just watching the Lions today. Jed Adcock is still 29 and is being delisted by Brisbane. He was an absolute gun hbf not that long ago and still seems to have his smarts. Worth taking a look at, I'd say.

I've always thought highly of Jed Adcock and think he should find a spot on someone's list. I'm surprised the Lions let him go.

He's probably not the right age profile for us however. We already have a number of players vying for that smaller defender type with Jones seemingly anointed as Shaw's replacement. We also have Marsh and Newman putting in good performances in the reserves this year and should challenge for those spots as well. With a full midfield it is also possible that Macca will be called upon to play in defence as well. I noted that Mills played in defence for the reserves, perhaps foreshadowing his starting position before making his way into the midfield.

I don't think Jed would like to be a depth player at this point in his career.

[jono2707]

With Bennell being a West Australian both Freo and the Eagles might prefer Bennell over Jetta.

I was thinking this too (the first part of this post anyway). Whilst Bennell is obviously a high risk, if a WA club gets him they may not go after Jetts as well...

[Mug Punter]

I was thinking this too (the first part of this post anyway). Whilst Bennell is obviously a high risk, if a WA club gets him they may not go after Jetts as well...

I wouldn't expect a club would be able to arrange a trade for both.

Both those clubs fit the profile of a club that would be prepared to take a punt on Harley.

I just have a feeling that Jetta is 50/50 re his future, conflicted is how AFL.com.au described it. And I can see why, he became a leader that day at the WACA and I just can't see how he could go back and play for that mob

[snajik]

Jetta is such a joy to watch. It would really hurt us to lose a player with such exceptional skills. I'd advocate going all out to keep him. A four year deal with co-captaincy included. He's a leader of this team now in all but name.

[Mug Punter]

Jetta is such a joy to watch. It would really hurt us to lose a player with such exceptional skills. I'd advocate going all out to keep him. A four year deal with co-captaincy included. He's a leader of this team now in all but name.

I'd be pulling out all stops and no problem at all with a four year deal, and with the new TV deal coming in we should be able to back end it a bit to make it competitive. Really really hoping he stays

[The Big Cat]

On Footy Classified tonight Craig Hutchinson said the word on the street is he's off to the Weagles.

[707]

On Footy Classified tonight Craig Hutchinson said the word on the street is he's off to the Weagles.

If that's the case we don't want WCE finishing too high as otherwise they'll only have a very late teens first rounder to trade.

[caj23]

I've always thought highly of Jed Adcock and think he should find a spot on someone's list. I'm surprised the Lions let him go.

He's probably not the right age profile for us however. We already have a number of players vying for that smaller defender type with Jones seemingly anointed as Shaw's replacement. We also have Marsh and Newman putting in good performances in the reserves this year and should challenge for those spots as well. With a full midfield it is also possible that Macca will be called upon to play in defence as well. I noted that Mills played in defence for the reserves, perhaps foreshadowing his starting position before making his way into the midfield.

I don't think Jed would like to be a depth player at this point in his career.

I normally don't advocate going for players in his age bracket, but at his best he is a 1st 22 player for our team taking over the role that Mal used to play. Wouldn't cost much either