Not sure if we have the talent to be rated at least second best list. Maybe Longmire has got the most out of an above average list with a game plan based on pressure and structure. Like all clubs, we will make some changes but shouldn't throw the baby out with the bath water .
Longmire.
Collapse
X
-
-
I think Dermott B. Got it right. Longmire is a great coach for preparing players to compete at AFL level. He is an ordinary game day coach.Not sure if we have the talent to be rated at least second best list. Maybe Longmire has got the most out of an above average list with a game plan based on pressure and structure. Like all clubs, we will make some changes but shouldn't throw the baby out with the bath water .
Sent from my iPad using TapatalkComment
-
If you're talking about Friday's game, wouldn't have mattered what he changed. We were off the pace, fumbled and made poor decisions. Dermott just one inflated opinion, like Garry Lyon who also never coached. Ridiculous conclusions are drawn from one game every week.Comment
-
Gee, you've... really hit Stevenson sensitive spot.., Barry. ??
Stop being such a wimp Stevie.Comment
-
With the attitude the players had, no game day changes would have altered the result. Just his game day choices are almost unheard off. Rohan and Cunningham cannot handle finals football, should have not played. Buddy does not have the mental strength to handle finals either. He should have been used as a decoy on the wing, and maybe attract a good defender away from defence. You have to make selections to suit the particular game. Cannot expect the same side, will work week in week out.If you're talking about Friday's game, wouldn't have mattered what he changed. We were off the pace, fumbled and made poor decisions. Dermott just one inflated opinion, like Garry Lyon who also never coached. Ridiculous conclusions are drawn from one game every week.
Sent from my iPad using TapatalkComment
-
Comment
-
So now Buddy is a liability in finals as well. If this is the case, what a performance by Longmire to get to 2014 and 2016 Grand Finals!With the attitude the players had, no game day changes would have altered the result. Just his game day choices are almost unheard off. Rohan and Cunningham cannot handle finals football, should have not played. Buddy does not have the mental strength to handle finals either. He should have been used as a decoy on the wing, and maybe attract a good defender away from defence. You have to make selections to suit the particular game. Cannot expect the same side, will work week in week out.
Sent from my iPad using TapatalkComment
-
Barry, please just stop. It's very, very tiresome reading the baiting and abusive posts.
Your good ones are interesting, but they are too few and far between. And the rubbish like the above ones in between disrespects fellow supporters and the club we love.Comment
-
Amazing what people add on. Can you point out where I used the word liability? He is the best full forward in the AFL. However over the last 3 finals exits, he has managed one goal. A champion yes, finals champion, maybe no.
Sent from my iPad using TapatalkComment
-
Really? I mean really?! I think Buddy has proven himself over the years in finals as a Hawk and a Swan. You'd use the Coleman medalist as a decoy? Not mentally strong? You don't think it was the massive haematoma and the mattress strapped to his thigh that might have been a significant contributor to that poor performance?Buddy does not have the mental strength to handle finals either. He should have been used as a decoy on the wing, and maybe attract a good defender away from defence. You have to make selections to suit the particular game. Cannot expect the same side, will work week in week out.
And before people say he shouldn't have played, if he didn't play and we lost like that - or worse - there would have been baying that he should have.
Sliding doors & we'll never know, but I personally think a half fit Buddy was worth a punt. We had no one to replace him with anyway. If you wanted a decoy, they should have played Tippett as he is a good physical foil up forward to take one of the bigger defenders from Buddy (but at that point in time, Tip's form and body simply didn't warrant his selection).Comment
-
I not interested in a coaching change.
I am also not interested in glorifying the south Melbourne period of our existance which was so unsuccessful, it forced the club to relocate. It's part of our history, but a mostly poor part.Comment
-
You said he can't mentally handle finals therefore fair conclusion to draw that he is a liability in finals. Your words.Comment
-
Is this the same Buddy who played one of the best quarters ever played in a final, one legged last week?Comment
-
Obviously people' s brains are turning to mash after the poor performance. If a midfielder gets 20 possessions we say he had a good game, if Dangerfield only gets 20, we say he had played an ordinary or even poor game. I am. Making reference to his high standards, nothing about being a liability to the side!!!!!!
Sent from my iPad using TapatalkComment

Comment