Match Day SEMI FINAL Geelong v Sydney MCG 7.50pm Friday 15 September

[Scottee]

Liability? Who else would you have played? I suspect he's injured. He's definitely double teamed much of the night. His confidence is down (reflected by his accuracy). And I don't think he's our worst tonight

When he can't even kick the easy shots, because, as you say, he is down on confidence, and he is basically your only forward, yes, he is a liability. And no, there is no one else to use.

Sent from my SM-T805Y using Tapatalk

[Swannette]

So much better with the commentary on zero, but my friends have to put up with my swearing at the selwoods and every missed swans tackle. Sadly there are many.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

[Boddo]

Considering the expectations pre game, this has been one of the most disappointing Swans finals performances ever. I can't believe I am saying for the second season in a row.....roll on Big Bash, just two weeks earlier this year. Extremely disappointing but in a way not surprising....they've been mentally tested and 'on the edge' for about 18-19 weeks now and they're shot.

2014 ring a bell.

[Ludwig]

It's silly to even bother talking about selection mistakes when our best players are having such poor games. Kennedy, Parker, Buddy and Rampe all getting hammered, so it's hard to blame the bottom six. It's just one of those nights. It happens. Console yourselves by thinking: "Oh well, we probably would have lost to Adelaide anyway."

[stevoswan]

Well done Cats. Awesome performance.
Pity the bugger who put $100k on the Swans.

It's a mugs game......he'll learn, maybe.

[MattW]

This has been the main problem from the first bounce. Add to that shocking kicking for goal, missed handballs, missed tackles. It's been a shocking night all round.

I know people on RWO love bashing Longmire but no coach can overcome the skill errors we have made tonight.

Yes, although that's in part down to attitude, which he has some responsibilty for. Tonight reminds me of earlier in the year when the Swans players looked like they all had headphones on. Heads went down early.

[goswannies]

Why was buddy allowed to play? He is no where near right?

Are you kidding me?! Even a half fit Buddy would be picked. Who would you replace him with?! If he wasn't picked and we lost like this RWO would be in meltdown over his non-selection. I'll put your question down to frustration.

[Agent 86]

Considering the expectations pre game, this has been one of the most disappointing Swans finals performances ever. I can't believe I am saying for the second season in a row.....roll on Big Bash, just two weeks earlier this year. Extremely disappointing but in a way not surprising....they've been mentally tested and 'on the edge' for about 18-19 weeks now and they're shot.

2nd to 2014 GF. But close.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[stevoswan]

2014 ring a bell.

It's definitely up there with that.....

[troyjones2525]

Once again Jones fumbles under pressure...

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk

[Agent 86]

Can't handle favourite tag


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[stevoswan]

Nice way to honour McVeigh boys......gee I hate milestone games.

[Odysseus]

It's silly to even bother talking about selection mistakes when our best players are having such poor games. Kennedy, Parker, Buddy and Rampe all getting hammered, so it's hard to blame the bottom six. It's just one of those nights. It happens. Console yourselves by thinking: "Oh well, we probably would have lost to Adelaide anyway."

+1

I think some RWO-ers don't recognise the coaching masterclass Longmire is giving. When Josh Kennedy holds aloft the 2018 premiership cup, he'll reveal the secret: "It all began when Horse gave us an extra coupla weeks before the summer break. We missed out on it going into 2017, and it was the ruin of us."

[Daisi]

Oh dear - sitting here in the Olympic stand with some very disappointed Sydney fans - next year is our year - nothing going right for us tonight

[goswannies]

Once again Jones fumbles under pressure...

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk

Well we've got a couple more years to improve his game