Why Hall Why????
Collapse
X
-
whats disgusting is you bunch of so called supporters.
I dont defend what he did and he should get 3-4, he wasn't even looking at him when he threw it. however you can clearly see him looking at the umpire, with staker holding grabbing all over him, i totally blame the umpires with the frustration that has caused him to snap. Week after week he cops more than he gives with no reward and he does his best to keep cool and to his credit its been how many years you lot...5. since his last major indiscretion..
You all applauded him etc in 2005 now you are all over him...shame shame shame you so called supporters...
i am still surprised no one has mentioned glass pushing Hall near the boundary, which i believe caused him his collision into the fence. Even the commentators clearly missed it..did anyone else see it. surely not i called it even before he hit the fence.
he will be missed, but we have the additonal fire power and structure to make up for his absence and we will give the cats a run, as long as we attack that is the key, only shut down if we need to...Comment
-
Comment
-
I thought it was a bit of a shrug off from Hall, did look nasty on the reply though. I'm sure he wouldn't blatantly punch the guy, but the evidence might suggest otherwise.whats disgusting is you bunch of so called supporters.
I dont defend what he did and he should get 3-4, he wasn't even looking at him when he threw it. however you can clearly see him looking at the umpire, with staker holding grabbing all over him, i totally blame the umpires with the frustration that has caused him to snap. Week after week he cops more than he gives with no reward and he does his best to keep cool and to his credit its been how many years you lot...5. since his last major indiscretion..
You all applauded him etc in 2005 now you are all over him...shame shame shame you so called supporters...
i am still surprised no one has mentioned glass pushing Hall near the boundary, which i believe caused him his collision into the fence. Even the commentators clearly missed it..did anyone else see it. surely not i called it even before he hit the fence.
he will be missed, but we have the additonal fire power and structure to make up for his absence and we will give the cats a run, as long as we attack that is the key, only shut down if we need to..."In some ways we?re less predictable to ourselves and sometimes that can be detrimental because we don?t really know where we?re going" - P.RoosComment
-
His time off for his injury will outlast his suspension.
Silly, silly boy blind barry.Wild speculation, unsubstantiated rumours, silly jokes and opposition delight in another's failures is what makes an internet forum fun.
Blessed are the cracked for they are the ones who let in the light.Comment
-
Comment
-
Given that Davis gets 3 weeks in the 2's (more if Hall wasn't out) for not playing to team expectations how many games in the 2's will Hall have to play before he can get back in the team? He was still carrying on like a tool for the rest of the game.
Mind you it was no way a king hit. He threw his arm without looking where it was going to hit.Comment
-
No Charlie for Blind Barry this year.Wild speculation, unsubstantiated rumours, silly jokes and opposition delight in another's failures is what makes an internet forum fun.
Blessed are the cracked for they are the ones who let in the light.Comment
-
What? We aren't allowed to express our opinion that a so called "team leader" let him team down in the worse why possible. That a "team leader" punched another player square in the jaw. How can you or I or anyone defend that?
It was uncalled for and quite rightly fans of this club have a right to upset with one of our "team leaders". I know I think its the lowest act I've seen on the football field in my time watching football. If Hall was the player on the receiving end of the punch everyone on here would be crying Blue Murder and hence therefore, we are correct when we call out Barry Hall for his actions tonight.
Yes, lets all blame the umpiresI dont defend what he did and he should get 3-4, he wasn't even looking at him when he threw it. however you can clearly see him looking at the umpire, with staker holding grabbing all over him, i totally blame the umpires with the frustration that has caused him to snap.
Face the simple fact that
a) the umpire was close to the incident and saw nothing Staker was doing was against the rules and most important of all
b) Barry Hall made up his OWN MIND to roll up his fist and throw the punch.
He knew the umpire wasn't going to pay him a free kick and he knew what he was doing and where it was headed when he swung his arm towards Staker. So the "wasn't looking" and "blame the umpires" cards are thrown out the window.
Ohhhh Barry has been a good boy and hasn't done anything bad in 5 years, so lets not be mean to him when he punches someone in the head....Week after week he cops more than he gives with no reward and he does his best to keep cool and to his credit its been how many years you lot...5. since his last major indiscretion..
Sounds like a logical idea
Regardless of how good on the field he has been at keeping his cool, it doesn't hide the fact that he still punched someone and is going to be out for 4-6 weeks because of it. He could be a Saint for all I care, it doesn't excuse punching someone in the jaw.
Yes we must all be nice to him because he was the Captain of the Premiership Team in 2005, gee doesn't that tell you something about why he SOULDN'T OF DONE what he did tonight??? Of are you just grabbing at straws there??You all applauded him etc in 2005 now you are all over him...shame shame shame you so called supporters...
I think Glass pushing Hall as slightly as he did wouldn't had the impact it did if the fence was protected in the proper way for ALL PLAYERS. Blaming Glass for Hall's injury is wrong because it was not an act of football that cause the injury but a unprotected fence. If at the SCG, Hall would have no injury to you grab onto....i am still surprised no one has mentioned glass pushing Hall near the boundary, which i believe caused him his collision into the fence. Even the commentators clearly missed it..did anyone else see it. surely not i called it even before he hit the fence.
Grundy or Davis will come into the side with the weather in Geelong and matchup being the deciding factor, if Grundy is fit to play (otherwise there is no question who comes in).he will be missed, but we have the additonal fire power and structure to make up for his absence and we will give the cats a run, as long as we attack that is the key, only shut down if we need to...Once was, now elsewhereComment
-
It was an idiotic and cowardly act by Hall. What is more idiotic is that some Swans supporters around me were cheering the hit from Hall. Supporters like this are not needed by the club.
..And the Swans are the Premiers...The Ultimate Team...The Ultimate Warriors. They have overcome the highly fancied Hawks in brilliant style. Sydney the 2012 Premiers - Gerard Whately ABC
Here it is Again! - Huddo SENComment
-
Mickey'O 34 Goals 17 Behinds (66%) 10 Goal assists
Club Games Record HolderComment
-
Comment
-
..And the Swans are the Premiers...The Ultimate Team...The Ultimate Warriors. They have overcome the highly fancied Hawks in brilliant style. Sydney the 2012 Premiers - Gerard Whately ABC
Here it is Again! - Huddo SENComment

Comment