We got pick 32 when we originally traded him for Vez. Did we win? I think so.
Trade Whispers / Rumours and Confirmations
Collapse
X
-
Comment
-
Comment
-
Sydney
In: Franklin (RFA), #32, #44
Out: Armstrong (delisted), Everitt, Lamb (delisted), Mumford, White
Picks #15, #32, #35, #44, #53, #71Comment
-
Comment
-
Agree that it's a poor return, but we lost 3 players outside our best 22 plus a high quality ruckman who was superfluous because of structural reasons. None of the players we lost would have an impact on 2014. We've got plenty of young players moving up through the system and a few reasonable draft selections to restock.Comment
-
We got perhaps the best player in the league plus picks 32 and 45 for our injury plagued second ruckman (who we were only willing to give two years to) and three fringe players all of whom are outside our best 22.
Big Big win when everyone was predicting we'd have to cut stars! Especially when we have upgradeable standard rookies coming out our ears.
- - - Updated - - -Those who have the greatest power to hurt us are those we love.Comment
-
Actually just Mummy, White, Lamb, Everitt for picks 32 and 44.
Agree that it's a poor return, but we lost 3 players outside our best 22 plus a high quality ruckman who was superfluous because of structural reasons. None of the players we lost would have an impact on 2014. We've got plenty of young players moving up through the system and a few reasonable draft selections to restock.
They are three excellent depth players, at the least, and like every club we will have injuries, which like this season puts these players in and around our best 22.
Added to that, all three possibly having their best footy ahead of them.
But the worst loss, IMO, is loosing Mummy... that's a big loss.....
Going into the season with only 1 genuine , AFL standard, ruckman on the list...All it takes is a training mishap (Pyke injured) and we'll struggle.Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it's time to pause and reflect... MTComment
-
Assuming that Armstrong is delisted, which is expected, would could take 4 ND pick and upgrade 4 rookies, so it gives an opportunity to our rookie list players to join the primary list. I would guess we could upgrade Rampe, Biggs, BJ and Lloyd.Comment
-
NO NO NO
We got perhaps the best player in the league plus picks 32 and 45 for our injury plagued second ruckman (who we were only willing to give two years to) and three fringe players all of whom are outside our best 22.
Big Big win when everyone was predicting we'd have to cut stars! Especially when we have upgradeable standard rookies coming out our ears.
- - - Updated - - -
Also Mummy was not 100% physically. Great impact when fit. But clearly the club had question marks.Comment
-
NO NO NO
We got perhaps the best player in the league plus picks 32 and 45 for our injury plagued second ruckman (who we were only willing to give two years to) and three fringe players all of whom are outside our best 22.
Big Big win when everyone was predicting we'd have to cut stars! Especially when we have upgradeable standard rookies coming out our ears.
- - - Updated - - -
We got unders on all of them but you need to look at the big picture. I'm not sure you can keep blokes on reasonable salaries as purely 'depth players' either.Bloods
"Lockett is the best of all time" - Robert Harvey, Darrel Baldock, Nathan Burke, Kevin Bartlett, Bob SkiltonComment
-
Comment
Comment