1st QF Swans v Giants

[barry]

Stop ya sookin.

[stevoswan]

I did. He runs toward him. How he hits him is inconclusive. It doesn't look even a hard hit.

You are F blind.....and Joey's wobbly legs and inability to stand up mean nothing I suppose.

[barry]

Gws nearly doubled our score. Could have trippled it if they kicked straight. The game want decided by a few isolated incidents. It was a capitulation.

[Scottee]

2005 we lost in the first round of the finals & it all turned out ok.

2015 Hawks did the same.

But I'm worried about the injuries (JPK, Tippett & Mills). JPK & Tippett didn't look great but probably needed to stay on if able, to remain competitive. Mills, even a lowgrade strain would probably need a little rest. Concussion to Tippett would be a concern given his history.

I think I'd rather a fit Nankervis than a half fit Tippett.

Sent from my Nexus 10 using Tapatalk

[Industrial Fan]

@@@@ off Barry.

It was one of the cheapest shots you'll see. I know you like fishing but that is even less defensible than your stance on that crappy stadium.

[Scottee]

Thought Horse made a good point in his press conference when asked about the hit on Joey. "There wasnt a free kick paid so musnt have been much in it ????"
Said it 3 times. Think he might of been having a subtle dig there at the imps.

Yes, very subtle.

Sent from my Nexus 10 using Tapatalk

[Cheer_Cheer]

Stop ya sookin.

You are a GWS supporter.. Please leave this forum to Swans supporters.

[Velour&Ruffles]

I did. He runs toward him. How he hits him is inconclusive. It doesn't look even a hard hit.

Sorry but this is total crap. He hit him off the play, knocked him in the head and did so with such force that he had the staggers. If that doesn't get a suspension then I'm giving up watching this @@@@in game. Seriously. There is no way that a guy with 16 previous guilty visits to the tribunal can get off that unsuspended unless there is behind the scenes rigging. But that rooster-sucker Fitzpatrick will presumably have the ultimate call (given Gillon the Eunuch is merely a puppet).

[barry]

You are a GWS supporter.. Please leave this forum to Swans supporters.

Dont tell me who i can and can't support. When you get to 4000 RwO post... then you can question me. Upstart.

[dejavoodoo44]

We need to stop playing the victim. Just harden the f up players and supporters.

I think Johnson will get off with a fine. The vision is inconclusive and kennedy didn't have concussion.

Kennedy did have concussion. That was why one of the toughest players in the game was unable to get to his feet for a minute or so. However, I'm sure that our medical staff would have diagnosed it as mild, grade one concussion, whose symptoms had largely disappeared during the important time that he was sitting on the bench. The fact that it was a mild concussion was the reason why he was able to return to the field.

[Cheer_Cheer]

Dont tell me who i can and can't support. When you get to 4000 RwO post... then you can question me. Upstart.

I didn't tell you any such thing. I just wonder why you come here. You seem to just be a troll. This is a forum for Swans supporters.

[0918330512]

We need to stop playing the victim. Just harden the f up players and supporters

This coming from someone who has sooked on for years about a Fat Lady Stadium - which, in her final miserable outing, might have contributed just a little to Sydney's loss. We play the SCG better than that flog of a ground ANZ. I'm not using it as an excuse - I'm saying that crap stadium is history, so I don't want to read another post about it. Ever.
If you disagree, harden the F up.

[stellation]

I don't see any reason to jump on barry, I tend to agree the hit from Johnson looks incidental in the footage.

We were soundly beaten. Jeremy Cameron's 3rd quarter was pretty remarkable.

[dimelb]

Bottom line: the better team on the day won. Perhaps the AFL have created a monster, after the inadequately resourced experiment on the Gold Coast.

We didn't play to our expected standard: we are noted for our pressure and it was well below GWS's. We kicked wildly and randomly, partly because of their pressure and partly because we bombed into the forward 50 relentlessly instead of working our way into a position where we could kick to someone better placed. We are perhaps the best tackling team in the comp, but you wouldn't think so from today. The damage to Tippett and Josh K impacted on us significantly. The umpiring didn't cost us the game but at times made it extremely difficult to bounce back - the Heeney non-mark being the most obvious instance.

I share the view that the break didn't do us any favours, and it was a totally unnecessary move by the AFL anyway. I hope we've seen the last of it.

Mad Dog Johnson should get a fortnight's holiday. Mummy's sling tackles should also be punished.

I'd give Cameron BOG. Outstanding player.

[barry]

I don't see any reason to jump on barry, I tend to agree the hit from Johnson looks incidental in the footage.

We were soundly beaten. Jeremy Cameron's 3rd quarter was pretty remarkable.

Yes it was . Our backline seemed to be 1 quality, mature player down all game. I can understand the marsh selection on top of an already young backline. Then you add mills who mustn't have been fully fit. totally lost at selection IMO.