How long have we been in a premiership window for and how long to you expect to be in one? I would say that since 2012 we've been premiership fancies, how long are we supposed to keep it going for before we slip? I would argue that we are going through a rebuild, not a major Lions style rebuild but a rebuild none the less. Look at how many young players we've brought through in the last 2 seasons. If we can bring in a top 10 talent for Reid you would have to seriously consider it
2017 trading, drafting, list management
Collapse
X
-
-
Steve may would be an awesome pick up if we let go space in the cap"be tough, only when it gets tough"

Comment
-
It doesn't look like a good draft year this time around, but a couple of top 10 pick should still go down well. We could probably trade one to Hawthorn for their 1st round pick in 2018 which we might need to get Blakey.
I don't think he will be leaving GC and he's not a free agent, so would cost a lot in draft picks or players. Maybe if Reid went for a 1st round compo pick, we could trade that for May, and I can think of a couple of players I wouldn't mind throwing in as sweeteners. If he did play for us, I think we would make him a forward, because our back line is already developing well.Comment
-
Swap our first (or second if Reid jumps ship) for the Hawks 2018 first, clever thinking Ludwig.
I reckon Hawks will slip further next year with another round of retirements and key players ageing, plus most other lower clubs seem to have more upside right now than the Hawks.
Think we need Dustin Martin more than we need Steven May.Comment
-
I think it may have been to look at another option to get Aliir into the side. If Longmire likes the current defensive setup, then perhaps we could play one ruckman and Aliir forward or back, who could take a turn in the ruck along with Reid. It also may give us a positional Plan B in games, if we could swap Reid and Aliir between defense and forward, so if Reid's having a slow game up forward, then we could swap positions.Comment
-
Does Aliir play back up ruckman in the NEAFL? I can't remember seeing him do it in the few games I've watchedComment
-
Is there blood in the water and whose is it.
The Sydney Swans will consider all list options in trying to bounce back from a horror 2017
Jones or Reid or Tippett or who else.
Sent from my SM-G900I using TapatalkComment
-
They could do with 2 or 3 more ruck persons, you can never have too manyIs there blood in the water and whose is it.
The Sydney Swans will consider all list options in trying to bounce back from a horror 2017
Jones or Reid or Tippett or who else.
Sent from my SM-G900I using TapatalkComment
-
Comment
-
That "article" says nothing beyond the obvious - that clubs are always looking to try and improve their lists.Is there blood in the water and whose is it.
The Sydney Swans will consider all list options in trying to bounce back from a horror 2017
Jones or Reid or Tippett or who else.
Sent from my SM-G900I using TapatalkComment
-
That's an interesting piece, particularly that Ireland has spoken so frankly about Tippett. It does seem to suggest that if he doesn?t improve over the rest of the year (i.e. back to the form of last year) they'll try to move him on. I wonder what the issue is. It presents as effort, but perhaps it's ultimately confidence. Either way, he needs to get past it.Is there blood in the water and whose is it.
The Sydney Swans will consider all list options in trying to bounce back from a horror 2017
Jones or Reid or Tippett or who else.
Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
I think Tippett and Jack will play on Thursday, big games for both.Comment
-
Hi Liz, it is obvious and same for all teams, why mention it, and a quote from Ireland.
We normally go "dark' when trying to trade in the shadows, unless trying to create interest for other clubs.Comment
-
Comment

Comment