2025 List Management

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Dow
    Regular in the Side
    • Sep 2022
    • 803

    Originally posted by lwjoyner
    Dow, you have to be joking. Ollie whilst quet for a couple of games is a must for the seniors. Better than bice, lloyd and cleary (who joined him today) and J Mac whose kicking is chocking. Lucky to kick over a peanut.
    Sorry I can't agree, maybe ahead of Bice and Lloyd for different reasons - but ahead of JMac no chance and id prefer Cleary for what he could be come.

    I'd be happy to trade floreant if there are any takers, I don't dislike him I just think like Parker and Lloyd the team has grown passed him.

    Comment

    • Blood Fever
      Veterans List
      • Apr 2007
      • 4041

      Originally posted by Dow

      Sorry I can't agree, maybe ahead of Bice and Lloyd for different reasons - but ahead of JMac no chance and id prefer Cleary for what he could be come.

      I'd be happy to trade floreant if there are any takers, I don't dislike him I just think like Parker and Lloyd the team has grown passed him.
      McInerney was key to our fast start and is one of the first picked each week.

      Comment

      • Dow
        Regular in the Side
        • Sep 2022
        • 803

        Originally posted by Blood Fever

        McInerney was key to our fast start and is one of the first picked each week.
        Agree in many ways I feel when JMac is playing well the team is

        Comment

        • KSAS
          Senior Player
          • Mar 2018
          • 1772

          Originally posted by Dow
          I'd be happy to trade floreant if there are any takers, I don't dislike him I just think like Parker and Lloyd the team has grown passed him.
          Jay Clarke on First Crack last night suggested Florent to Carlton for Harry McKay. Intimating both are desperately needed by each.

          Florent signed 5 year contract last year. He deserved to be dropped and expect him to excel again in the seniors (same with Lloyd). Why are the media so quick to jump to conclusion players are on the trade table when they're dropped due to form?

          Comment

          • Roadrunner
            Senior Player
            • Jan 2018
            • 1453

            Originally posted by KSAS

            Jay Clarke on First Crack last night suggested Florent to Carlton for Harry McKay. Intimating both are desperately needed by each.

            Florent signed 5 year contract last year. He deserved to be dropped and expect him to excel again in the seniors (same with Lloyd). Why are the media so quick to jump to conclusion players are on the trade table when they're dropped due to form?
            Exactly, but there’s a difference between the two- I’m afraid Jake’s time maybe up, considering his age- hope I’m wrong! With Ollie it’s just a temporary loss of form/ confidence and so he should be back in the team soon. I wouldn’t trade him- if McKay wants to come to us, we’ll find a way.

            Comment

            • imuninformedtwo
              Warming the Bench
              • Aug 2024
              • 371

              Originally posted by Roadrunner

              Exactly, but there’s a difference between the two- I’m afraid Jake’s time maybe up, considering his age- hope I’m wrong! With Ollie it’s just a temporary loss of form/ confidence and so he should be back in the team soon. I wouldn’t trade him- if McKay wants to come to us, we’ll find a way.
              And let's remember, the Melb media version of this trade is Ollie PLUS our first rounder, for McKay - a guy who makes Joel look like a dead eye dick at times.

              I'm open to just taking the three academy boys in the draft, given it's regarded as a poor one otherwise. I think it was Cal Twomey that said any of the top seven from last year's draft would easily be a clear no1 this year, and it lacks real quality. But we're not that stupid.

              Comment

              • lwjoyner
                Regular in the Side
                • Nov 2004
                • 947

                Jay Clarke (ist crack) suggests Ollie +2 picks to Clues for H McKay. npt to sure about this though. what say others

                Comment

                Working...