2021 trading, drafting and list management: players and personnel
Collapse
X
-
-
Jimmy Bartel thinks Reid needs to play back next year
“I don’t think he can play forward anymore”: Bartel calls for positional switch for Swans veteran
Largely because (1) there’s no spot for him forward (2) we need help down backComment
-
I think Bartell forgets that we tried this strategy when Grundy was injured. Same was OK for 2 out of the 4 or 5 weeks he played there. Then in his third game back he had a bag kicked on him. The runner was going out constantly asking him to tighten up. There was no Ted, retired, no Rampe, injured. There was a patchwork backline that just wasn't working. Sam just simply does not do enough of the defensive work a back needs to do. He is great as an extra but when he has to man up he has been found out.Jimmy Bartel thinks Reid needs to play back next year
“I don’t think he can play forward anymore”: Bartel calls for positional switch for Swans veteran
Largely because (1) there’s no spot for him forward (2) we need help down back
Sent from my JAT-L29 using TapatalkComment
-
Comment
-
Matthew Lings highlights reel looked better than Corey ....... and Corey and Lingys high light reels look better than Chad's
What do we do with this information given how good Chad has turned out already from back of the pack on draft day?
2min videos just confuse me even more ????"be tough, only when it gets tough"

Comment
-
We do nothing. We wait for the recruiting staff to do it.Matthew Lings highlights reel looked better than Corey ....... and Corey and Lingys high light reels look better than Chad's
What do we do with this information given how good Chad has turned out already from back of the pack on draft day?
2min videos just confuse me even more ????Comment
-
The highlight reel for Chad was pretty incredible. It was almost exclusively defensive plays and 1%ers. Which you rarely see from prospects reels. There was nothing glamorous, but a clear hunger and competitiveness.Matthew Lings highlights reel looked better than Corey ....... and Corey and Lingys high light reels look better than Chad's
What do we do with this information given how good Chad has turned out already from back of the pack on draft day?
2min videos just confuse me even more ????Comment
-
What is there to know ? a nobody from the murdoch rag will not change my mind so not worth putting money into his pocket as you sayComment
-
I'd previously posted on here I was wary re Goater as the snippets I'd seen suggest his style resembled Elliott Yeo but his kicking resembled Andrew Dunkley (though we love Dunks).
This 'highlight' reel I came across the other day suggests I was being generous re the kicking. Yikes!
Goater Vic M v Vic C - YouTube'Delicious' is a fun word to sayComment
-
I just liked the look of his highlights package.....didn't notice too many bad disposals but if those knocks on him are true, yes that could certainly change things.Comment
-
Without wanting to send us all down a rave wormhole, are you saying that the Goat kicks like a mule?I'd previously posted on here I was wary re Goater as the snippets I'd seen suggest his style resembled Elliott Yeo but his kicking resembled Andrew Dunkley (though we love Dunks).
This 'highlight' reel I came across the other day suggests I was being generous re the kicking. Yikes!
Goater Vic M v Vic C - YouTubeComment
-
Wow, that's not the package I saw but your right, his disposal was awful. I think I've changed my mind.I'd previously posted on here I was wary re Goater as the snippets I'd seen suggest his style resembled Elliott Yeo but his kicking resembled Andrew Dunkley (though we love Dunks).
This 'highlight' reel I came across the other day suggests I was being generous re the kicking. Yikes!
Goater Vic M v Vic C - YouTube
Comment
-
I have a hunch we will end up with Corey Warner. If so, would we be drafting him with pick 16, or would we take our chances and hope he's still there at pick 31?"Unbelievable!" -- Nick Davis leaves his mark on the 2005 semi finalComment
-
Comment
-
Highlight reels are that - the highlights, and it is limited by how much video there is available of the matches that clearly show it was that player at a good enough angle/distance to include it.
As the Geelong coach said, if you just look at the five minute highlights of Gary Rohan, you would think he was the best player in the country!Comment

Comment