2022 List management, trading, drafting

[bloodspirit]

Not sure that this is the best thread for it, but here is the official official confirmation: Sydney Swans duo set to retire.

[bloodspirit]

Could there yet be a fairy tale end for Cal Sinclair? If Hickey is injured would we recall Sinclair, or Amartey, or play with no rucks?

[Ludwig]

Could there yet be a fairy tale end for Cal Sinclair? If Hickey is injured would we recall Sinclair, or Amartey, or play with no rucks?

I think we would go with Reid and Amartey instead of Sinclair. His football has fallen away considerably this year and he's had some really poor games. That said, who knows if he will have a revival of form next week with Ladhams out and a chance to play finals. So nothing is truly definitive. Longmire always says things can change quickly in football.

[bloodspirit]

Sinclair lifted and had a good game in the reserves against Casey on the weekend.

[MattW]

Good news: Sam Reid has been extended again for next year - AFL: How veteran Swan Sam Reid found his groove again | news.com.au — Australia’s leading news site.

Great quotes in that one, thanks.

[Nico]

In the draft I would be going for the best ruckman available.

[Ludwig]

In the draft I would be going for the best ruckman available.

It's a waste of a draft pick. Most of the best ruckmen come from the rookie draft. It takes years to develop a ruckman, then they usually fall over or leave the club. It's the biggest long shot in the draft. Even the ones that seem a success, like Brody Grundy, sign a big long term contract, then go into effective early retirement, sticking the club with a huge hole in their salary cap.

It's more likely that Peter Ladhams will become a rocket scientist, and the Swans will fly to the moon on his back.

[111431]

It's a waste of a draft pick. Most of the best ruckmen come from the rookie draft. It takes years to develop a ruckman, then they usually fall over or leave the club. It's the biggest long shot in the draft. Even the ones that seem a success, like Brody Grundy, sign a big long term contract, then go into effective early retirement, sticking the club with a huge hole in their salary cap.

It's more likely that Peter Ladhams will become a rocket scientist, and the Swans will fly to the moon on his back.

if we want a ruckman why aren't we talking to Grundy? Pies can absorb part of his salary and he would an excellent addition to our team. He and Hickey would be a powerful combination while Ladhams learns to think of the team instead of immature rushes of blood to the head.

[dejavoodoo44]

It's a waste of a draft pick. Most of the best ruckmen come from the rookie draft. It takes years to develop a ruckman, then they usually fall over or leave the club. It's the biggest long shot in the draft. Even the ones that seem a success, like Brody Grundy, sign a big long term contract, then go into effective early retirement, sticking the club with a huge hole in their salary cap.

It's more likely that Peter Ladhams will become a rocket scientist, and the Swans will fly to the moon on his back.

I dunno, there's been some pretty good ones taken high recently. Luke Jackson, Tim English, Luke Darcy's son, Ben.

[Ludwig]

I dunno, there's been some pretty good ones taken high recently. Luke Jackson, Tim English, Luke Darcy's son, Ben.

Of course there have been some great ruckmen taken early in the draft, but the vast majority have been taken round 3 or later, with many taken in the rookie draft. Even Freo's Ben Darcy was taken in the 3rd round.

We are stuck with Hickey and Ladhams in the meantime. I would send Ladhams to off season therapy. I'm running a session in January which includes 6 free dental implants (anesthetics extra), which would have Peter as docile as a lab rat when it's done.

[Southern Swan15]

Taryn Thomas anybody?

Sent from my SM-A715F using Tapatalk

[707]

Taryn Thomas anybody?

Yes please, could be a seriously good player based on his second half of last season but has had issues this year. He might really blossom in a better team and away from the Melbourne fishbowl.

[Nico]

So we are going into the next few years with Ladhams as our no.1 ruckman. Sam Reid has signed for one more year and the only other at this point is Amartey. Cal Twomey had the first ruckman at around pick 18. I reckon we have one or two years to develop a drafted ruckman otherwise Papley may indeed be playing ruck.

[Blood Fever]

So we are going into the next few years with Ladhams as our no.1 ruckman. Sam Reid has signed for one more year and the only other at this point is Amartey. Cal Twomey had the first ruckman at around pick 18. I reckon we have one or two years to develop a drafted ruckman otherwise Papley may indeed be playing ruck.

Hickey still around for 2 more years I would have thought.

[Nico]

Hickey still around for 2 more years I would have thought.

Yes, but.....will his body stand up to it? Melbourne are after Grundy because they can't expect Gawn to do the heavy lifting alone. Maybe we are talking to Grundy.