Trade target discussion (merged thread)

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Conor_Dillon
    On the Rookie List
    • Jun 2013
    • 1224

    Definitely not sold on Sinclair...hard to see where his improvement is going to come from.
    Twitter @cmdil
    Instagram @conordillon

    Comment

    • longmile
      Crumber
      • Apr 2011
      • 3366

      Read somewhere that we're not going after Talia anymore or we couldnt land him? Can anyone confirm? Would have thought he'd be a good fit

      Comment

      • troyjones2525
        Swans Fanatic!
        • Mar 2008
        • 2908

        Agree that Sinclair whilst serviceable doesn't really appear to stand out as a #1 ruckman, which is what we need. Also Jetta being a former first round pick who has played many great games in his career and has certainly done a lot more than Sinclair should not be just a straight swap! We have to play hard ball and demand their first round pick and not settle for another #2 ruckman with little more upside than he's already shown this year. Then perhaps use that pick to try and snare a Lobbe, Smith or Leunberger who have all shown promise of being legitimate #1 ruckman and certain stages in their careers!
        Last edited by troyjones2525; 8 October 2015, 11:24 AM.

        Comment

        • The Big Cat
          On the veteran's list
          • Apr 2006
          • 2356

          Remember that Sinclair is a forward/ ruckman in a similar sense to Tippett. I think maybe the Swannies see value in having two ruckmen who can change up forward and still be dangerous goal kicking options. Unfortunately Pykey is not that type of player.
          Those who have the greatest power to hurt us are those we love.

          Comment

          • Mug Punter
            On the Rookie List
            • Nov 2009
            • 3325

            Originally posted by The Big Cat
            Remember that Sinclair is a forward/ ruckman in a similar sense to Tippett. I think maybe the Swannies see value in having two ruckmen who can change up forward and still be dangerous goal kicking options. Unfortunately Pykey is not that type of player.
            I am happy to have two Ruck cum Key Forward Tippo style ruckman as I think pehaps they will make us a little more unpredictable and hard to match up on

            Comment

            • Triple B
              Formerly 'BBB'
              • Feb 2003
              • 6999

              Originally posted by Levii3
              He didn't have a great GF he's 26 now, he's an elevated rookie i think so probably him and maybe their second or third round pick and use that in the trade with the dogs for Talia if we're still going after him.
              Sinclair was very poor on GF day, but his previous two efforts, particularly the QF when he was close to best bigman on the ground were first class.

              Hard to expect a sweetener because he had a bad final game when we're swapping him for a guy who stunk it up the last month or more and who appeared to not give an absolute rats tossbag in his final game...
              Driver of the Dan Hannebery bandwagon....all aboard. 4th April 09

              Comment

              • Industrial Fan
                Goodesgoodesgoodesgoodes!
                • Aug 2006
                • 3318

                Originally posted by Triple B
                Sinclair was very poor on GF day, but his previous two efforts, particularly the QF when he was close to best bigman on the ground were first class.

                Hard to expect a sweetener because he had a bad final game when we're swapping him for a guy who stunk it up the last month or more and who appeared to not give an absolute rats tossbag in his final game...
                Shhhh.....dont let that get out.
                He ate more cheese, than time allowed

                Comment

                • crackedactor
                  Regular in the Side
                  • May 2012
                  • 919

                  Originally posted by Triple B
                  Sinclair was very poor on GF day, but his previous two efforts, particularly the QF when he was close to best bigman on the ground were first class.

                  Hard to expect a sweetener because he had a bad final game when we're swapping him for a guy who stunk it up the last month or more and who appeared to not give an absolute rats tossbag in his final game...
                  Being poor on GF day does not mean much. Even Nic Nat had only 4 disposals. I would still accept him in a swans Guernsey. I think Sinclair would be a good get for the Swans. Also heard that Witts from Collingwood is another possibility, originally from NSW. Have not seen much of him though.

                  Comment

                  • Go Swannies
                    Veterans List
                    • Sep 2003
                    • 5697

                    Originally posted by crackedactor
                    Being poor on GF day does not mean much. Even Nic Nat had only 4 disposals. I would still accept him in a swans Guernsey. I think Sinclair would be a good get for the Swans. Also heard that Witts from Collingwood is another possibility, originally from NSW. Have not seen much of him though.
                    I've never met any Witts from Collingwood. Lots of half witts though.

                    Comment

                    • 111431
                      Regular in the Side
                      • Sep 2010
                      • 698

                      Originally posted by crackedactor
                      Being poor on GF day does not mean much. Even Nic Nat had only 4 disposals. I would still accept him in a swans Guernsey. I think Sinclair would be a good get for the Swans. Also heard that Witts from Collingwood is another possibility, originally from NSW. Have not seen much of him though.
                      the Pies fans don't rate Witts so I don't think we should go there

                      Comment

                      • Plugger46
                        Senior Player
                        • Apr 2003
                        • 3674

                        I've seen plenty of Witts. Developing well in my view - played some decent footy earlier in the year.
                        Bloods

                        "Lockett is the best of all time" - Robert Harvey, Darrel Baldock, Nathan Burke, Kevin Bartlett, Bob Skilton

                        Comment

                        • Melbourne_Blood
                          Senior Player
                          • May 2010
                          • 3312

                          Originally posted by Conor_Dillon
                          Definitely not sold on Sinclair...hard to see where his improvement is going to come from.
                          The ruck whisperer ...

                          Comment

                          • stevoswan
                            Veterans List
                            • Sep 2014
                            • 8559

                            Originally posted by Melbourne_Blood
                            The ruck whisperer ...
                            .................I hope we have one!

                            Comment

                            • Melbourne_Blood
                              Senior Player
                              • May 2010
                              • 3312

                              Originally posted by stevoswan
                              .................I hope we have one!
                              I was under the impression we did, has Steven Taubert retired ?

                              Comment

                              • stevoswan
                                Veterans List
                                • Sep 2014
                                • 8559

                                Originally posted by Melbourne_Blood
                                I was under the impression we did, has Steven Taubert retired ?
                                I know nothing!(Spoken in Schultz voice!).....especially about the inner workings of the club, other than what I read on here. I didn't realise Taubert was so good as a ruck coach, or if he's with us still or not. I hope he is then. As I said, I know nothing!!

                                Comment

                                Working...